Thursday, 05 November 2009
-
Being Fat Should Never Be OK

Last week in my abnormal psychology class we started up the chapter on eating disorders. Today we went over Bulimia and Obesity. Obesity is not regarded as an eating disorder yet but it's going under consideration. Our professor asked us our opinion on the subject and here is mine (real quick and short):
I don't believe obesity should be looked down upon and obese people shouldn't be made to feel ostracized. But we should in no way help them feel better about their condition. By sugarcoating the problem we only become enablers. I might be fat, but I don't want fat to be okay.First off we treat fat like it's a bad word by hiding it. Instead of fat we call ourselves "curvy", "plump", or title ourselves as "more to love".
We need to stop covering up the truth with cute words and admit it: We are fat.
I don't want it to be taboo.
Here are the statistics so far:
*United Kingdom: 1980 - 2002 prevalence of obesity nearly tripled*China: in 1989 1.5% of children considered obese. 2002 the percent rose to 12.6.
*United States: as of 2006 33% of adults considered obese.
This is not a problem only in the US. This is pretty much world wide. But I think we all knew that.
Whenever a fat post gets posted up on health kicker, how many people do you see come out with "My whole family is big, it's genetic." or "I have a thyroid problem."It's not genetic. It's habitual. You do what your family does, and you eat what your family eats. If your family spends most of the day watching TV and eats out a lot or eats heavy meals regularly then its your habits, not your genetics that's the problem.
I can't get a straight answer but from what I see only maybe 10% of women actually have a thyroid problem, and not even that full 10% equals to weight issues. I doubt that health kicker just happened to be where everyone with a thyroid problem congregates.
I'm not saying there aren't people with thyroid problems and that there aren't people with genetic problems. I'm just saying it's probably not you.
I'm saying take responsibility for what you've done to yourself.
I don't remember fully but there was a story awhile back about a couple school zones that wanted to change the sizes on school uniforms to accommodate the bigger (read: fatter) children. Basically what would be medium sized uniforms would be labeled "small" and large sizes labeled "medium" and so forth. And I totally disagreed. If your child is a large, don't try to lie and make her feel better by reading a label that says medium. If she's fat she's fat and it's better she/he knows the truth and works on correcting their health.
Basically: Don't ostracize obese people. But don't sugarcoat the problem either. Because they'll probably just eat that too.
Do you agree with this post?
Post a Comment
- Back to lovelyish's Lovelyish Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in lovelyish's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)



True












Comments (323)
Being anorexic, bulimic, and/or starving yourself should never be okay either.
People are freaking out, and I'm so tired of reading about this. "Stop hating on skinny girls!" "Stop calling 'fat girls' curvy!" "Real women have curves!"
Oh my god. Stop it. If you are happy, then who gives a shit what everyone else thinks?!
I completely agree.
That thyroid issue, sorry but its bullshit.
I had a thyroid 'problem'.
& its very easily fixable.
The pills didnt do anything.
the exercise did.
Atleast thats how I feel.
Stop trying to deny that youre fat.
@katiwitz@xanga - agreed.
Basically: Don't ostracize obese people. But don't sugarcoat the problem either. Because they'll probably just eat that too.
hahahahahah. & yes i agree
I just think that some people are labeled fat, when they are just average. Some people think that normal looking people are fat just because they think that really skinny people are normal.
LOL.
"Basically: Don't ostracize obese people. But don't sugarcoat the problem either. Because they'll probably just eat that too."
this post is just asking for controversy..
but i love the last line. and i agree, uniform sizes shouldn't be switched to make you feel better about being fatter.
the picture made me puke a little bit in my mouth.
We live in a culture where EVERYTHING is justified and sugarcoated (not literally). Guilt and blame just don't exist anymore, same as self-responsibility.
You're skinny? Fat? Have a disorder/disability? Can't sleep? It must be stress, genetics, social factors, etc.... anything but you.
So I agree.
i agree, to a point. we shouldn't sugarcoat things. when someone is medically obese, health problems are almost always going to ensue. but that doesn't mean we shouldn't have a little compassion. it's like the people that say "eat a sandwich!" to an anorexic. compulsive eating is a psychological problem, and berating people for it completely undermines the hurt that person may be feeling. you don't know what caused them to be this way, so it's not our right to judge.
also, some girls really are just "curvy" not "fat". it's perfectly natural to have some curves. that doesn't mean you're "fat" or unhealthy, but that's what so many girls think these days..i know that's what i thought for a long time. nowadays girls that aren't even medically overweight are considered "fat" if they have some meat on them, because being very thin is the only thing considered attractive practically. and this is SO wrong. someone who is say, 10-15 pounds overweight (like in that picture you posted!) isn't necessarily at risk for diseases. so i for one am glad to see people that embrace their (healthy) curves. i would rather see that then people starving to try to avoid being called "fat" when they aren't even fat to begin with.
i certainly think that people like to make excuses (i.e. slow metabolism, genetics, etc.) but only they know the real reason why they are overeating. so i would never put someone down for it. it comes from a place of pain, just like eating disorders like anorexia and bulimia do. so try to remember that.
Bravo.
There's a big difference between being "big-boned" or having "more to love" and being obese. Obesity = unhealthy. You can have a larger body type and still be healthy.
Sooo....basically you want to yell at the fat people, but you dont want to be too controversal in doing it..hmm...
Personally...I don't mind being fat at all, and I don't care if other people are fat, as long as people are happy, who cares...Way back in the roman days, the bigger you are, the more attractive and healthier you were, go figure. (And don't break it down to some stupid specifics).
YOU don't have to be ok with being fat, but for the people that really don't care..let them don't care.
I think being curvy is okay. But there is a fine line between being curvy and being fat. I honestly don't understand how far people let themselves go. I do think obesity is a problem, but we cannot force people to lose weight. they have their free choice to do whatever they want with their bodies. We cannot stop them. They just have to face the facts one day.
w00t!
aesthetics change with time and often align with whatever is harder to attain. in the old days, fat was beautiful because it suggested leisure and opulence. it was never healthy and no longer connotes this. things that aren't healthy (and aren't congenital) should not be lauded, and this goes for both ends of the spectrum.
I agree
curvy does NOT equal fat. or obese and how are thyroid issues bs? and no, not every single person ever is fat through their own fault. there are people who eat little but gain weight cuz of medication that they're on or have gained weight cuz of diabetes and so on and so forth.
haha. I was totally talking about the Medium to Small in a post I just wrote about pant sizes. I agree that we should be honest and that people need to be more accountable for their weight. For some people, they really do gain weight easily, because of genetics (thirft gene; conserves all energy), but for a lot of people, we're just not eating right or getting a work-out.
Seriously, this is what is wrong with America today. We concentrate on looks and all this crap instead of finding true happiness. So what if someone is bigger than the "ideal" size? (What is the "Ideal" size anyhow?) If they're happy, and they're healthy (yes, big people can be healthy and big) then let them be. It's a bit ridiculous that we emphasize beauty is a size 0 or a size 1. Some of the most gorgeous people are big. Why don't we focus on that once in a while?
Bout time someone says the truth.
wow. Just wow.
Yeah. Because we wouldn't want people who aren't an exact ideal to feel good about themselves.
The cheeseburgers are clogging up your brain.
Lets make sure we tell cancer patients how shitty they look bald too. We wouldn't want them to think cancer is okay.
honestly...i think the real problem is that people associate "fat" with "unattractive" so when you call someone fat, youre really saying theyre undesirable, if that association wasnt there, I think it would be more acceptable. Its understanding to not accept obseity if its purely from a health issue, but its also not your business to criticize someone elses flaws, just because you can openly see them, god knows we all have our own flaws. You dont necessarily need to go about this by sugarcoating fat by calling them "curvy". BUT what you should say is, "youre beautiful the way you are, but Im worried about your health, for that reason you should lose weight"