Saturday, 29 November 2008
-
The Media's Influence: What's Your Ideal Beauty?
Guest blog submitted by walden_thoreau
Today, I met a 13 year old girl.
"If I was skinny, I'd be pretty." I just stood and stared when she said that.
She was quite lovely, but could not have weighed more than 80 pounds.Yes, this was the picture she was looking at.
"She's beautiful. Don't you think?" she asked me.
Quite honestly, I had to think about my answer. Obviously, this isn't a photo of a beautiful woman. This is a photo of thin sex. Sex used to sell a fragrance that doesn't even smell that good. Advertisements like this only solidify the fact that a woman's value is her youth and beauty. (A man's has always been his productivity, or potential productivity.) In today's world, a woman's "worth" to society peaks on her wedding day; a man's increases perpetually.IT IS A SAD DAY WHEN OUR YOUTH USES 'THIN' AS A SYNONYM FOR 'BEAUTIFUL'.
I did my best to explain to this girl that beauty is multifaceted, whereas being thin like the girls she sees in magazines is God playing Russian Roulette with metabolism. Real girls don't look like that. Airbrushing and anorexia are the keys to landing yourself on the cover of a magazine.
Then she smiled, and said, "Maybe I am beautiful."Dearest Media,
Kiss my beautiful, size 10, healthy ass.
Love,
Faith.Have you ever struggled with body image and/or overcame an eating disorder? How big of a role do you think the media plays into self-esteem issues?
Post a Comment
- Back to lovelyish's Lovelyish Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in lovelyish's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)

















Comments (221)
The media is ridiculous.
It's sad when you hear a 13 yr old say stuff like that.
I work in advertising, and am constantly airbrushing pics, so I know it isn't real.
Plus growing up, the only insecurity I had was that I wished I was taller. I'm 5'3" now and 25.
Other than that, I admit, I was always the skinny kid amongst my friends.
I also was the one with the big boobs (they kinda appeared over night. Sort of.)
What upset and irritated me the most was when people would say.' Oh you're so pretty, if only you were taller'.
I'd be irritated beyond words!
I'm 15 right now, and I've been struggling to have a healthy and accepting perception of my body for a few years now. It's just my family always joke about my size(when it's really not that funny at all) and I'm always around people who are all thinner than me, sometimes it can get a little too much. Even though I'm probably not even considered fat to most people.
i am 13, and have never had an eating disorder, but have thought a lot about them. i guess im not fat, but im not skinny either... i go 2 a private catholic skool and mostly everyone there is naturally-born skinny. 3 times have i been called fat by fellow classmates. once last yr in 7th gr during sci. once this yr at our 8th gr retreat by a boy wo is larger than me. once this yr...... by a teacher. i just told all of these ppl to basically go fuck themselves and told them that i dont care wut they think of me. well, this is how i let them see me. inside, i am very self concious. this past week was thanksgiving break and out of 5 days, i starved myself for 3. a couple of weeks ago, my own uncle said i had teachers arms. i just told him to look in the mirror cuz he has a muffin top. idk y im telling u this. i guess its cuz im happy 2 finally let some1 kno my feelings... the night of this incident, i turned on the shower and blared the music. i attempted 2 gag myself. however, i could not make myself do it....
anyway, i just wanted 2 tell u that a lot of young girls my age have A LOT of insecurities because of todays society. its a dreadful thing, really. i mean, who would want 2 be an anorexic modelthat has bones showing everywhere? eww..
but, in despise of everythin ive typed before, i somewhat admire anorexics for their self control :)
i like how u posted this story. it really made me realize that i should be happy with my body. thnxz u :)
It seems like most of the wrong people have incorrect perceptions about their body. The skinny (usually) girls that think they're fat. And the mass majority of Americans who are overweight or even obese but think they're fine.
I once got extremely sick and my lowest was 90lbs. But in eight months I gained 35lbs back and I love it! I'm healthy and I feel great.
But the media does affect a woman's self-esteem. It really puts down those girls who do not see that the women we see on television and in print ads are not "real" women.
LOL i'm glad you said that to the 16yr old
the problem with the media blitz of unnaturally gorgeous, unnaturally thin girls is that it really hurts the young girls. i'm talking about the age group from 5-19 or so. see, the damage to a women's psyche with these ideas of unattainable thinness being mixed into being unattainably pretty is done EARLY. the only way to keep these crops of f-ed up young women from growing is to keep the young girls from getting messed up in the first place. and good luck with that, because i've been trying to keep my younger cousins from that path, and she's 10 and worried about her weight and making sexy poses in photographs. >_<
@CrissySomedays - totally agree!
my ideal beauty is to look healthy and glowing, no matter what size you're.
i am super skinny and very underweight since the day i was born. i have been struggling with this unhealthy body for a long period of time. i feel it's an unfortunate when everyone's jealous of my petite size. honestly, i rather be big but healthy than skinny and unhealthy.
recently, my younger sister has discovered that her friend suffers from anorexia. and how old is she? eleven years old.
our perception of beauty is sick.
it's been imprinted into our brains... it's sad but we really need to set a new standard...
The other day, I stumbled across some girl's xanga, and I was horribly sickened by the pictures and words she had posted. All the comments encouraged and congratulated her on her weight loss. I soon realized that all of these girls set a goal weight and kept track of all the were eating. Some at less than half the calories recommended a day and others ate 700 calories a week. I left some comments but I think it was useless.
k so yeah the picture is gagworthy but eva mendez is hotttt.
im a full 8 and wouldnt mind looking like her but thats not my goal in life. the media is so horrible. the media does a lot of things. makes girls hate their lives. wins presidencies. supports luxurious lifestyles and anything but is just not good enough. the media is always upping the standards. and they are so unbelievably unrealistic.
and you are beautiful! :)
What a great post
"Advertisements like this only solidify the fact that a woman's value is her youth and beauty. (A man's has always been his productivity, or potential productivity.) In today's world, a woman's "worth" to society peaks on her wedding day; a man's increases perpetually."
I AGREE COMPLETELY!!!! Not agree with the stupid societal values, but agree that that really is how society sees women and men, and it annoys the crap out of me!! And you put it eloquently too, thumbs up.
I absolutely HATE when girls self-depricate their appearances for attention, or even if they really "hate" their bodies.
Love the username too..walden thoreau, haha. Oh transcendentalism.
Yes, Yes, and I think the media should stop being dominated by gay men, who determine that the ideal woman should be taller than the average man, and weigh less than the (5'4") average woman, even though she's 6+ inches shorter...
WOMEN. MEN ARE NOT ATTRACTED TO THIS, UNLESS THEY ARE ATTRACTED TO MEN.
Just remember that.
I have serious problems with my body image. I'm fat and ugly, to put it simple. But I've never brought into the whole super skinny is beautiful. Bones sticking out scare me. Even when I was young, when most girls were worshipping supermodels and super slim movies stars, I was in awe with their curvier counterparts, ala Marilyn Monroe. I prefer America Ferrera over Mary Kate/Ashley.
I've had an eating disorder, believe it or not, at 6. My family's always called me Little Ms.Piggy when I was young... prolly the main reason why I had it. I've overcome anorexia and bulimia, but still my self-esteem's really low. I still think that I'm not beautiful. Its been years (I'm 17 now), but the effect of how my family stained my confidence level is obvious.
I struggle with it every day. I went from the ideal thinness in high school to a size eight in about two years. I'm still struggling to see myself as beautiful, healthy, and normal. I think that women everywhere are going to struggle with this until they die.
I struggled with an eating disorder for five years and it made me want to die everyday. I struggled both with the physical problem of being slightly overweight (like 15 pounds, though during puberty that's not uncommon) and the desire I had for attention and acceptance as I grew up basically fatherless and without much male approval. I've since overcome it all with help from my faith (I'm a Christian) and I've learned to love my body, slowly and surely. It's not an easy road, and women in general are just attacked for how we look. I won't blame the media because it's too great of a cause-- I'll blame myself on this one and how I believe the lies sometimes that thin is beautiful. I will tell other girls (especially younger ones) and believe myself in our inherent beauty and focus on health and fitness, not simply thinness. I want to just hug and hold and never let go the girls I know in my life, and I try to tell them that they are naturally gorgeous no matter what, and that beauty is such a diverse thing. The problem truly doesn't lie within the media- it lies within us, and our acceptance of their untruths. I hope someday it will end, and the definition will be widened, so that no other girl ever has to go through what some of us have.
THANK.YOU.
yes i have struggled with my body image once, for about ten minutes and then i realized how ridiculous i was for even thinking i needed to be skinnier!
it was during summer time when everyone wears bikinis...(do you see where im going with this) A LOT of my friends are SUPER skinny and are curveless. but then there is me....i have curves, im not stick thin, and i have an ass. one day i got back from a day at the pool and i was looking in the mirror and i thought that i needed to loose weight. so then i went down to my kitchen, opened the pantry, and grabbed my mom's diet mix that you stir into milk. so i placed a big clump of it into a tall glass of milk and gulped it down hoping that if i drank as much of this as possible then i would be skinnier and look like my friends. IT WAS DISGUSTING! absolutely HORRIFIC! i never tasted it again and i realized how stupid i was being! from that point on i promised myself that i would always think i was beautiful no matter what and never drink that horrible diet shake again!
im not fat, but im not stick thin either. im perfect. and i wont strive to be anything else because im not one dimensional.
the media is playing with women's minds and men's as well and its just not fair.
*size ten asses are beautiful. cause mine is...*
generally people dont perceive themselves as beautiful, but other people can pick up on it. i was playing a tournament, and a woman was speaking to my mom...
"is 25 your daughter?"
"yes she is"
"she's gorgeous. she has such beautiful proportions..."
its all proportion, and a shitload of confidence, i would assume. not promising to have any sort of concrete answer, though. i have self esteem issues myself, i just found it quite interesting.
<3
did she actually say that? "Maybe I am beautiful"? Haha that sounds like bad dialogue out of a cheap feel-good book. what an air head.
the media only shows us what we want to see.
i'm 5'4 and 88 pounds, and it's gross.
as "ideal beauty" goes... i guess i'd like to gain a bit of weight (20 pounds maybe) and go up a cup size (i'm barely a b at this point).
i don't know, inner and outer beauty seem to get mixed after awhile. like, you can see someone's personality on their face once you've gotten to know them.
I'll be lying to you if I say the media have not affected my body image at all. In fact, it affected everybody in some way little or big. Instead, you should ask how much the media have affected your body image? That would be much more accurate.
I heard some people rather have a flat chest to be thin then to have full size body. And when I say full size body I mean there is meat on the body where it should be. I personally, like my body they way it is most of the time. Occasionally, on holidays there someone calling fat like my sister in-law. She's a size zero. So, comparing me to her she thinks I look like a cow.
Good on you for making a positive difference in someone's life!
I can't believe the amount of beautiful women I talk to who deny their beauty. I take pictures of them to prove it, and then they give all the credit to me for making them beautiful. I can only take a picture of what's already in front of the camera. It sorrows me that all of these women have their perceptions controlled by magazines and ads. Ridiculous.