Saturday, 29 November 2008

  • The Media's Influence: What's Your Ideal Beauty?

    Guest blog submitted by walden_thoreau

    Today, I met a 13 year old girl.
    "If I was skinny, I'd be pretty." I just stood and stared when she said that.
    She was quite lovely, but could not have weighed more than 80 pounds.  


    Yes, this was the picture she was looking at.
    "She's beautiful.  Don't you think?" she asked me. 
    Quite honestly, I had to think about my answer. Obviously, this isn't a photo of a beautiful woman. This is a photo of thin sex. Sex used to sell a fragrance that doesn't even smell that good. Advertisements like this only solidify the fact that a woman's value is her youth and beauty. (A man's has always been his productivity, or potential productivity.) In today's world, a woman's "worth" to society peaks on her wedding day; a man's increases perpetually. 

    IT IS A SAD DAY WHEN OUR YOUTH USES 'THIN' AS A SYNONYM FOR 'BEAUTIFUL'.
    I did my best to explain to this girl that beauty is multifaceted, whereas being thin like the girls she sees in magazines is God playing Russian Roulette with metabolism. Real girls don't look like that. Airbrushing and anorexia are the keys to landing yourself on the cover of a magazine.
    Then she smiled, and said, "Maybe I am beautiful."

    Dearest Media,


    Kiss my beautiful, size 10, healthy ass.

    Love,
    Faith.

    Have you ever struggled with body image and/or overcame an eating disorder? How big of a role do you think the media plays into self-esteem issues?

Comments (221)

  • two_days_until_forever

    I'll be honest - I suffered with body dysmorphic disorder for years. My self-perception was so off that I really thought I was much heavier than I truly was and much uglier than I truly was. You see yourself as very ugly and not the way you really look. You could stare in the mirror for hours, focusing on 'flaws.' You stay inside in isolation and avoidance, missing school or cancelling events, from anxiety based upon your appearances. You have very low self-esteem, you are depressed, you may suffer from social phobia and anxiety attacks. I had all of that and severely. It took me so long to build myself again and to develop confidence. I think it's okay to strive to be more beautiful (I believe all women are beautiful initially) and to take care of yourself, as long as you do so in a healthy manner.


    To the media, yes, there can be pressure - but you have to be strong and realize that who you are is more important than who "they" tell you to be.


    ~~Mary~~

  • Tiger11007@xanga

    My idea of beauty is being just the way that I am. Not in pleasing others. I'm the one that has to live with myself...not the world around me.

  • la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga

    My ideal beauty is somewhat different from that which media portrays, and instead more of what people prefer.


    For women, I like a short frame, pale skin, dark or vibrant red (not orange!) hair. Big hands with long, thin fingers, extremely tiny waist and large hips with a round ass. Small rib cage and narrow shoulders, with large natural breasts. Long legs (relative to frame, not necessarily relative to anyone else), and bright green eyes. Oh, and thick lips! That would be awesome.

    For men, broad shoulders, tall(!), facial hair, short dark hair, medium-to-dark skin. Arms proportionally big relative to torso (no scrawny torso with huge hulking arms, or vice versa). Amazing abs (!) Narrow hips. Round ass. Strong legs. Large hands! Thick lips, and bright green or brown eyes. Oh, and a nice penis.

  • elittlebear@xanga

    I think the media influence of ideal beauty in the city I am living in now, its "not" the ideal beauty in my mind.

    This media influence is so twisted and making people think sexy (on the lusty perspective) is the way of pretty coz men would want you. I don't think beauty is based on men would want you.

    And I think thin is the NOT only ideal of beauty. I say not only, coz everyone is different regarding body figures, and they can all be beautiful. "...coz I am beautiful in every single way..."

    Some people are thinner and some are fuller, yet they all can be beautiful.

    *And when there is different, there is comparation (there nothing evil nor good), it's the end statement / conclusion, that precieve +ve or -ve.

    @Tiger11007@xanga - agree

  • StrawberryRose53@xanga

    As that child matures sexually, she will look around to see if she is "pretty" in relation to the other girls.  There's no stopping it, just if she becomes confused and jumps into fire.


    Females between 17 - 30 make healthier babies.  That's why males are attracted to them.  More productive males tend to be able to provide for their offspring/ have a higher quality potential. It's evolution.   


    Some girls really do look like that naturally.  I sat next to a model on a plane that seemed insecure about her beauty, and I was like, why would you be?  I mean she was kind'of dumb, and she wasn't being rude at all.  It's just like, some people get lucky while others do not.  //Sigh


    It seems like you are trying to tell that 13 year old that she needs to be more like you, does she?  Are you insecure?  Let me help you feel better... go into a drawer and pull a picture of yourself from 5 years or so ago.  You will notice that you were a lot prettier than you thought you were and that you are prettier now than you realize :)  You have to work with your own beauty.  That is, if you care.  The girls on the covers seem to sell themselves and fade quickly. They work for the cover, clothes, school and evolution.  It's a serious job, apparently.  Do you really need to put that much effort forth every day? Do you like the taste of cotton balls? 

  • peacelove__CALLIE@xanga

    It sounds a lot like you are saying thin people are not beautiful. I know A LOT OF GIRLS who ARE THIN, and DO LOOK perfect. OF COURSE the media is going to photoshop things and air brush, its for display, its entertainment. Its like saying that cartoons shouldn't be cartoons because they are not realistic. Makeup, and modeling, and fashion, is an art. Its there to be dramatic, and overdone. The point isn't to look "natural" or anything like that. Plus, just because someone is very thin doesnt mean that they aren't healthy. A lot of younger girls at just thin because they havent really grown up yet. It happens, and they can even be considered underweight but are way healthier than you and I will ever be. 

  • PerkyPunk8064@xanga

    I don't think anyone's ugly. Everyone has a different view of beauty. I overcame bulimia, which I was from the ages of 16-20 (i'm 22 now). I used to throw up 9-11 times a day, and now i've thrown up probably 4 times this entire year (january-november; not too bad! :D).


    I think everyone's beautiful though- thin, fat, short, tall, and everything inbetween.
  • Sangdaoh@xanga

    Media has a lot to do with everything.  Especially what younger girls believe to be "beautiful" or "trendy".  Everything's a big fad now... like being skinny.  I admit, in my teen years.. and even now sometimes, I feel a bit inferior compared to the girls on the cover of the magazine, but eh, you should just be happy with yourself. ^_^

  • TakingxOverxMe@xanga
  • Sangdaoh@xanga
  • nsantoro@xanga

    i have struggled with anorexia and i think the media is 100% what causes these kind of issues. It sets (dangerously) thin as the standard of beautiful in everyone's mind. When everyone around you reinforces the ideal image that the media produces; it hard not to give in especially at a young, impressionable age.

  • monomial13@xanga

    you know what guys, the real beauty's the inner you. the physical appearance doesn't matter that's why thank God for your God-given image. Start reflecting on your personality cause it matters.

  • Katherine_the_third@xanga

    Yup.
    I've been through that.
    Since being away at University, i've really come to love myself. but my self-doubt and anxiety has transfered into relationships instead of worrying about what I look like.
    I'm still working on it

  • princess_serenity07@xanga

    i think i'm pretty... but i'm fat, so i don't think i'm pretty enough.


    but the thing is. i'm a smart girl who's almost graduating college. i give health teaching (as a nursing student) to people of all ages and sizes and i even manage to help psych patients. i should know better.


    and i do. i know i shouldn't be this way. but in my mind, i'm still not worth going out with cuz i'm fat. =(

  • ozzieong@xanga

    I think that beauty comes in all shapes and sizes. Though I do get pissed off when people say that real women are curvy. I am a naturally skinny girl. I did not go on diets to be like this.

    I love curvy women, though. Which is why when it comes to pressure from the media, I actually want to gain weight. But we should love ourselves for what we really are. I cannot be bothered changing myself anymore. It gets tiring.

    That picture of Eva Mendes - it's airbrushed but she IS beautiful, nevertheless. Not because she is thin, but like I said, beauty comes in all shapes and sizes.

  • youdo_ntknowme@xanga

    @peacelove__CALLIE@xanga - I don't think she's saying that people who are thin aren't pretty, but rather that you don't have to be thin to be pretty. That they aren't synonymous--you can have one without the other, or you can have both....

    Myself, I'm kind of, well... fluffy, and sometimes I'm hard on myself for it, but I'm not complaining b/c its my own fault I'm too lazy to do anything about it.
    But I'm content with myself anyways.

  • AnnabelJones@xanga

    The media plays such a HUGE role in self perception. In a psychological study, girls were given a short time to look at magazines. I can't remember the exact duration, but it was short. Based on their responses on a questionnaire before and after looking through the magazines, their self esteem had decreased quite a bit.

    It's hard to believe that you are beautiful when all you see around you is what you aren't. I have struggled with my body and self esteem quite a bit growing up. Now I can see the beauty in the mirror, but before I couldn't. I never had problems with eating disorders, but I could have been a good candidate had other things in my life been different. A lot of what the problem is that we have a "perfect" image drilled into our heads. We end up wanting to look like that "perfect" girl. Since "perfect" is far from unattainable, we can do nothing else than fail. This then keeps the vicious cycle of trying to reach "perfect" going.

    One of the most important things I have learned over time is to embrace what you have. Whether you are small, large, short, tall.. someone out there envies you. Someone out there wants what you have. Maybe it's another girl who wishes to look as good as you, or a guy who sees the true beauty in your figure.

    Not all guys like a skinny girl. My boyfriend is good proof of that. I'm a size 14 in jeans, but many people say I don't look it. Whether or not I do, my boyfriend thinks I am beyond sexy. The next guy might prefer a smaller more fit body shape than mine, which is fine. Everyone has their own idea of what beauty is, and despite what the media may portray, everyone is beautiful. What can make or break that is your confidence. Being confident can only enhance your beauty.

    So be confident! :D

  • BrandNewColonial@xanga

    mm...surprised at some of the stuff folks are reading into this post. 
    Personally I like what you wrote. amen.

  • diane_florence@xanga

    media like magazines play a big influence on what people specially teens perceive to be beautiful, not just by the pictures they put but also by the contents they publish, we read about articles on how to be thin - thinner, or what are the star's diet regimen, etc. , and these seem to imply you have to be thinner, --otherwise would be undesirable. we as readers have to know better. my idea of beauty is whatever that makes the lips smile, whatever that makes the thoughts happy.

  • sWiMpRiNcEsS@xanga

    never had an eating disorder, but i feel for the people that have....its hard living in a world where the media is shoving the idea of "thin is beautiful" down our throats. Media does play a huge role in this, but most of my body issues came from my mom expecting perfection and an ex saying i should lose a few pounds after i gained the freshman 15....but i know for a fact that if you have other support systems out there (in my case, my awesome friends) then whatever the media says doesn't matter and you're just like, **** it, i'm beautiful and i love me for what i look like. I just wish that more people, young girls especially, could recognize that

  • hUoNgIeFeR@xanga

    Thin girls get their share too. I've never past a size 0 and have always been picked on for being thin. I think people of all sizes should be happy when themselves as long as they are healthy. Being too thin isn't healthy nor is being a fatass. 

  • CrissySomedays

    BDD too..

    But I got over it. You learn to love yourself. Sometimes you just need to dress up and have some fun in a photo shoot to see how beautiful your body is. I think it's a waste of time to mope and compare sooo much. You are stuck with your body. You can change your eating habits but an eating disorder, no? A better lifestyle, yes. I don't find model thin to be beautiful. Healthy is beautiful to me.

    Not many girls think that women in magazines are photoshopped.. they go "Oh, I want to look like that"  and well you can, someone can photoshop you too..

  • nepenthium@xanga

    "...whereas being thin like the girls she sees in magazines is God playing Russian Roulette with metabolism"

    ^ hahaha

    nicely put xP

  • methodElevated@xanga

    Beauty is largely about symmetry, proportion and indications about your fertility, health and ability to produce fit offspring.

  • CrissySomedays

    @hUoNgIeFeR@xanga -  yesss i agree. most people don't understand that gaining weight is difficult as much as losing is. it took me 2 years to gain 20 pounds and it was easily dropped last month.  

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About this Entry

Who gave the eProps?

2 eProps from:

1 eProp from: