As somebody who took a very long time to get over her body image issues (some of which still remain), I do not bother with freaking out over “Thanksgiving weight.” But every year, there are about 6 million articles on losing weight you may or may not have gained due to feasting with family and friends, so I’m forced to think about the topic. In my opinion, post-Thanksgiving dieting is a bad idea.
Believe me, I get it: when you’ve given into temptation several times within a matter of days, it can be difficult to feel at ease with your choices. Being healthy is important to many people, so that sort of stress can trigger a lot of guilt about what’s been eaten as well as fear of how it will affect your appearance. We’ve been trained to feel guilt when we do something “wrong,” such as eating cheesecake and pumpkin pie and ice cream and cannolis (example via personal experience three days ago), making Thanksgiving the prime time to step into the office of anxiety.
Upset thoughts such as “I’m going to look terrible in Christmas photos” or “I won’t be able to fit into the holiday dress I just bought” or “now my diet is ruined” may be running through your mind after a bit of a binge. But this type of mindset can lead to overcompensation with dieting, added stress and irritability towards oneself and others. Is that really how you want to spend December? Just worried about food and whether or not your waistline has bounced back yet?
Rather than inducing guilt, try to get overeating to lead towards a desire to strategize, not criticize. Simply adjusting back to a balanced, healthy diet will make your body feel better in a non-stressful way, as opposed to weighing yourself obsessively and restricting caloric intake. It’s the age old difference of going on a diet versus having a healthful diet: one is a temporary way to “solve a problem,” whereas the other is a lifestyle choice with no end date.
Keeping a mindset that involves rational thinking, planning and managing will help keep you from those guilty feelings. Did you pile on the sweet potatoes and stuffing too high? It’s all right, let it go! You’re not a failure, you’re not disgusting and you don’t deserve to be criticized, even and especially by yourself.
The fact of the matter is that you’ve likely spent the holiday with loved ones and some great food, which makes for wonderful memories. Think about how much fun you may have had making rolls with your aunt or the delicious texture and taste of your grandfather’s classic mashed potatoes recipe. Why dwell on the bad when so much good is sitting right there in mental snapshots?
Lovelies, do you partake in post-Thanksgiving dieting?
guest
No. I don’t overeat. With that said, I think this was a wonderful post. I think people should be able to enjoy the holiday with their family and friends without feeling guilty even if they do overindulge.
guest
I don’t overeat, I have one plate & I usually don’t eat over 300 calories the day before, and I don’t eat at all the morning of Thanksgiving until dinner. I just continue eating healthy afterward. Its not a ‘diet’ for me, its a lifestyle.
sunflower / 300 posts
@SUPletstake___surveys@xanga - You only eat 300 calories in a day? Fascinating. And, as I said, readjusting to healthy eating is a lifestyle choice!
@Erika_Steele@xanga - Thank you! I totally agree. xo
guest
Well, since 1) we don’t celebrate Thanksgiving in Mexico, and 2) I’m raw vegan, I don’t suppose I have to worry about it.
sunflower / 300 posts
@secretbeerreporter@xanga - 1) Mexico is awesome, I am jealous that you live there! 2) Good on you, seriously. As soon as some personal/health stuff clears up, I’m going to go back to a vegetarian diet and eventually vegan. Go you, madame!
sunflower / 300 posts
@secretbeerreporter@xanga - Dammit, I even thought about mentioning “unless you’re a guy, in which case, mister.” But alas, hindsight is 20/20.
guest
@samescobar - I’m a sir, but thank you anyway.
guest
I’m actually surprised I don’t stress out over it, considering my history with food. I think it’s because when I got obsessed with losing weight, I got obsessed with the scientific parts of it, like how on a normal daily basis just doing everyday things, you burn 100 calories an hour, so the way you should be eating is, if you eat a 300 calorie snack, you don’t eat until that’s burned off (so in 3 hours, unless you exercise) because calories that are consumed on top of calories that haven’t already been burned get stored. Ok, got a tad off topic there, but anyway, I know that there’s no way I could have gained more than a pound, maybe two, because I would have had to consume 7000 calories on top of the 1200 I burned by just being with my family & having fun.. so I just kind of think of it mathematically & tell myself I’m being silly.
guest
I don’t understand why people overeat on holidays like Thanksgiving and Christmas. You don’t need to eat until you can’t move to have a good time.
guest
no i dont stress about thanksgiveing weight.For some reason this Thanksgiveing I couldent eat a second Plate of food But I did mange to eat 2 pices of Pumpking Pie.
guest
@samescobar - Lol, not every day! Just the day before Thanksgiving. I drink lots of water and snack on fruits & vegetables throughout the day, so I’m not starving myself or anything. I should’ve worded that better in the first comment.
guest
No, because I’m not crazy about Thanksgiving food. That and my wheat intolerance mean that I don’t overdo it with stuffing and desserts.
guest
@daydreams_nightmares@xanga - Because by the time you get a little bit of everything, it still adds up to a lot of food. At least, that’s how things are for my family.
Honestly, the concept is not one that ever occurred to me and I find it odd. You’re just going to pig out again at Christmas, so I don’t see the point. Realistically, in one day, or even one weekend, of overeating, how much weight is a person going to gain? Probably not much.
sunflower / 451 posts
@VampireOfSeduction@xanga - My thoughts exactly. I don’t stress over it because it’s just one day. Every now and then, it’s okay to let loose and have a good time. Not everything has to be carefully planned all the time.
(Even though, I sometimes wish I could gain just a bit of weight over the holidays and look like I did back in college.)
guest
I have a wheat, corn, and lactose intollerance so I just made my own food and it was delicious
Paleo pumpkin pie, butternut squash, sweet potato biscuits, and then I had some turkey. I didn’t eat anything I wouldn’t normally.
guest
As someone who is currently dealing with some serious food anxiety (to the point of a disorder), this post had a very calming effect. Thanks, I think this is exactly what we need right now. I’m so sick of all the news stations talking about how the average American consumes over 4,000 calories on Thanksgiving and needs to go for the world’s longest jog.