After watching Undeclared on Netflix for an entire day, and wondering why I kind of find Jay Baruchel attractive… it was total coincidence that I came across this list of strangely attractive celebrities. Sometimes, what we consider to be flaws are what makes a person unique and beautiful in their own way.
These celebrities might not be the norm when it comes to what we picture as classically handsome or beautiful, but there is just something about them that is weirdly attractive. Check out these controversially attractive celebs.
[via Buzzfeed]
Do you find any of these celebrities strangely attractive?
You can see more from this gallery on Buzzfeed!













guest
I don’t think there’s anything strangely attractive about Jay Baruchel. He’s just attractive.
guest
I see how this works. Let’s compare a picture with make up against one without, a photoshoot picture against a candid shot, a picture in character with one out of character (especially if it is a photoshoot), or a photoshoot picture with one where the celeb has packed on at least 20 lbs (5 on their face alone). Then we will say that these people are oddly attractive. Oh wait, I forgot the goofy face non-goofy face comparison.
daffodil / 1615 posts
@Erika_Steele@xanga - Maybe I’m missing something, but I don’t find any of these people even moderately attractive, even in their photoshoot/professional pictures. They just look weird (aside from Adam Scott, who isn’t really weird-looking to begin with).
orchid / 103 posts
Gwendoline Christie is the dopest!
orchid / 160 posts
A beauty, a beauty!
AAAHH Crispin Glover. You would pick him, WOULDN’T YOU.
hydrangea / 58 posts
I think Alison Pill is cute, either way. She has that milk-maid innocent look.
guest
jay baruchel!
guest
allison pill is adorable! and hahaha after seeing the sorcerers apprentice i found an attraction to jay. he’s … quirky, and attractive
xoxo K
guest
Alison Pill!!!
orchid / 157 posts
Tilda Swinton is gorgeous to me.
And Benedict Cumberbatch…yum
hydrangea / 59 posts
I LOVE JAY BARUCHEL.
guest
I too love Tilda.. But the one left out, because she couldn’t be made goofy, is my all time favorite, Catherine Zeta Jones. Love the bone structure, and the combination of Welsh and Spanish seem to make for nice looking. I’ve always been too pale, now almost 60, with circles under my eyes. Ah yes, the unimportant things I complain about….
guest
Adam Scott is just the cutest! I love him. I never got the whole attraction to Benedict Cumberbatch until I watched Sherlock. Now I fully understand!
guest
Jay<3 *swoons*
guest
adam has a johnny depp pirate vibe to him with the beard/stache combo. he has sexy eyebrows. I don’t find him attractive clean shaven, but he’s cute as a fuzzy-faced pirate. it depends on the guy. some look cuter with beard/stache/goatee combo, while others look cuter clean shaven. benedict is sexier as a brunette. crispin’s flat hairstyle is creepy. kristen looks like hillary clinton. gwendoline kinda looks like jennie garth. rachel is the older and geeky version of nicole richie. vincent is like the chubby brother of heath ledger. jennifer is jessica simpson’s older sister. kate is adorable. sandra always looks like she has an UGH facial expression. lena looks very obnoxious. shelley looks like natalie imbruglia’s older sister. alison is cute. tilda looks like she hasn’t slept for years. I like jay’s hair but he looks too boyish for my preferences. they look like geeky versions of other celebs.
guest
Norman Reedus is one of these for me. I used to think he wasn’t particularly attractive. And then, suddenly one day, I was wrong and he was oh-so-fine.
guest
Benedict Cumberbatch is absolutely FLAWLESS as Sherlock.
guest
I love Jay Baruchel’s face but his voice, its just not an appealing voice. His voice sounds dorky which is a shame because a beautiful deep voice should accompany that handsome exterior!