Last Friday the minds behind DC comics gave their devout readership something to sink their teeth into: In the newest incarnation of The Green Lantern comics — wherein Alan Scott, the original Green Lantern hero, is young again — it will be revealed that Scott is gay. The news was received with fanfare the Internet-wide, for the most part.
It’s a realistic depiction of society. You have to move with the times.
said James Robinson, the series’ creator, to the New York Post. And it’s true. While some might view this as an opportunistic ploy to make a grand statement on a still touchy issue, the point is that whether or not everyone wants to talk about it, a lot of people are gay. While Robinson didn’t have to broach the issue, we can’t assume he did so solely to make a political gesture. After all he still has comic books to sell.
And as we might expect, one group in particular isn’t happy. The same one that protested the gay wedding issue of the Archie comics digest, and the same one protesting there existing a gay character in the Marvel series X-Men (he’s a wedding planner): One Million Moms. One “mom” tweeted:
Children desire to be just like superheroes. Children mimic superhero actions and even dress up in costumes to resemble these characters as much as possible. Can you imagine little boys saying, ‘I want a boyfriend or husband like X-Men?’
It seems that the whole world isn’t quite ready for a hero who plays for the Other Team. But perhaps that’s the point.
What’s your take on DC’s decision to have The Green Lantern “come out?”
guest
It doesn’t phase me. Obviously they’re probably going to get some negative responses but I’m sure they’ll also get plenty of positive ones. I think it’s kind of like what you wrote. Keeping in touch with the times and I think that ties in to their acknowledgement that there are people who look up to these superheroes and can perhaps offer some people some courage if they’re struggling with who they are.
guest
I though the point of comics is to reach all sorts of readers. Who says that gay boys don’t deserve a superhero like themselves?! Or, an even better question: who says that ALL children don’t deserve all sorts of heroes-men, women, gay, straight, handicapped, etc etc etc?!
guest
It always amazes me how much of a fuss there seems to still be in America over people being gay. It just really baffles me that a country so “western” still can’t get over the fact that some people are just gay. It’s not really a big issue and I honestly don’t understand why people even listen to the crazies protesting. How on earth do other peoples personal lives affect them? I think it’s extra confusing to me, being from a country where I’ve never even heard anyone be opposed to gay marriage. Literally never. Our prime minister is an openly gay woman and nobody gives a shit and of course nobody should. It’s just such an ancient way of thinking.
daisy / 598 posts
Aw it’s adorable, I love it!! Just ignore these wackos…it’s exactly the point that we want kids to feel comfortable wanting this sort of love, because it’s just as normal as any hetero love.
sunflower / 321 posts
@rabbitsarecool14@xanga - yeah, i’ll be really happy when this is no longer “newsworthy,” you know?
guest
I’m still surprised it wasn’t Robin who came out. That seems like a missed opportunity.
guest
“Can you imagine little boys saying, ‘I want a boyfriend or husband like X-Men?’”
No, I can’t, because that sentence doesn’t even make sense. Smart little boys (and girls) who read the comics have a better handle on grammar than that. Seriously? Out of one million of them, not one of them went, “Hey guys, I think ‘X-Men‘ refers to more than one person.”
Anyway, OMM needs to get the stick out of their ass and realise that a) reading comics won’t make you a homo, and b) kids are not the only ones who read comics.
hydrangea / 59 posts
@Rob_of_the_Sky@xanga -
We’re talking about Dick Grayson here? Or Damien Wayne? Damien is barely eleven, and as the current Robin, he probably wouldn’t really have anyone his age. If you mean the iconic Dick Grayson, he’s been with SO many women, human or alien, turning him gay would really change his character. If you turned Tim Drake, the current Red Robin, into a gay character, then that throws off the balance of the Teenage Titans having a representative from different cultures, Bunker being the homosexual and the Latino. Turning Jason Todd gay would be out of nowhere with the current run right now. I’m not touching up on the girl Robins with this reboot. (My reply ends here @-@)
So seriously, why are people making a big deal that one technically obscure character is being turned gay? He was the original golden age green lantern that casual people don’t know about, who was powered by mysticism and not by an alien thought-based construct-forming ring. The modern Green Lanterns in popular culture aren’t even the same as Alan Scott.
Seriously, with so many comic book characters who are already homosexual, bisexual, transgendered, transexual, etc., why worry about a character your parents probably only heard of as children? This sounds like an article to stir up emotions from non-comic book readers just to start issued about fictional characters they didn’t even care about. And no, I’m not even a devout comic book reader.
guest
What bothers me about all this is comics tend to have some really graphic fight scenes. No longer is it just the POW, BOOM ,BAM filling up a box. You have heroes being killed in many universes sometimes very brutally but groups like OMM don’t seem to care about any of that. They don’t mind children being exposed to violence, but a loving gay couple is just too much for them.
guest
My take on DC’s decision? They are trying to improve their rate of penetration in the youth market by creating some buzz where there really shouldn’t be any because there have already been plenty of characters of diverse sexual inclinations.
guest
i’ll be the lone ranger here…..i think it’s ridiculous.
guest
I hate that they’ve made it such a big deal that it needs it’s own announcement.
Why can’t the issue just come out and have a gay character in it?
guest
I think I prefer my superheroes to be asexual that was part of their appeal. It was their moral struggles with their sexuality that made complex and interesting. Now that they are coming to terms with it…they will lose some of that friction and become BORING. They are becoming to politically correct to keep me interested.
guest
@Rob_of_the_Sky@xanga - Robin sucks.
It should’ve been The Flash. For obvious reasons.
guest
We live in a freedom of speech country. They are free to publish the kinds of comic books that they want. I know some people of religious persuasions inappropriately protest this phenomenon in our country. However, I respect the rights of the Gay citizenry to debate the religious side of the argument, but routinely accusing the conservative citizens of being homophobic and bigoted is really attacking a straw man.
I had openly gay employees in my departments. They did fine work and were respectful of others as we expected straights the same. I never had any trouble with gays, straights or religious people.
daffodil / 1525 posts
@Grtt@xanga - I think they meant x as in whoever
sunflower / 255 posts
The yaoi fans shipped it before it was cool.
guest
@annamariuhh@xanga - I genuinely don’t think they did, considering the popularity of the X-Men. Even if they did, though, it still doesn’t make sense.
guest
That’s gay.
rose / 980 posts
Wait, what? They reinvented a character and now he’s young again? I don’t care if he’s gay, but why the heck reinvent a character. Why not just create a new character? Didn’t they just have the Green Lantern movie, and he wasn’t gay!
guest
@grizzlybearr@xanga - Thank you!
same here.
guest
This is weird. NOT because I don’t think gay/lesbians/bisexuals can be super heroes or awesome people, but I’m not sure if this is just trying too hard to ‘go with the times.’ It’s like the creators wanted a gay superhero for publicity or whatever. If the Green Lantern was created with the intention to be a character representing the gay community, all the power to them, but if this is just for attention, i’m not amused
guest
that’s hot
guest
It’s disgusting and wrong on multiple levels. I can’t believe they think this will help them sell more comics.
guest
That’s cool… It doesn’t really change my opinion considering I don’t read Green Lantern comics…
guest
ha, I’d like to see hollywood make the next green lantern sequel based on that! prehaps some man on alien man(another green lantern) action?
in response to a million moms, media has pushed the masculine prototype for so long that it’d be nice for kids(gay or other wise) to see that there are other equally acceptable ways to live
guest
@TiredSoVeryTired@xanga - I don’t know if anyone’s responded to this. The Green Lantern here (Alan Scott) is from an older generation that the Green Lantern from the movie (Hal Jordan).
guest
Oh and this all takes place in an alternate universe in the comics, so they’re not completely re-writing the character’s history.
rose / 980 posts
@Camouflaged_by_night@xanga - I didn’t know there was more than one Green Lantern! lol But alternate universe ones can make sense. Thanks.
guest
@TiredSoVeryTired@xanga - Alan Scott was the original Green Lantern (from the Golden Age). Hal Jordan was the second Green Lantern (from the Silver Age). He’s arguably the most famous Green Lantern, and the recent movie was based on him. Guy Gardner and John Stewart were the next Green Lanterns, but they aren’t as well-known as the others. Kyle Rayner is the current Green Lantern in the comics.
guest
@Rob_of_the_Sky@xanga - or aquaman!
guest
@RazielV@xanga - My husband agrees with you… I still say aquaman >.<
guest
@TiredSoVeryTired@xanga - Theve’ been reinventing tons of characters and story lives… such as gothem is now arkhem.
guest
one million moms is such a joke. i liked ellen’s take on it: “for a group that calls itself one million moms, they only have 40,000 members on their page, so they’re rounding to the nearest million, and i get that.” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zNKTTtAXCs
apparently now their facebook page has mysteriously disappeared. winners.
guest
Didn’t marvel do this first?
guest
@TiredSoVeryTired@xanga - They re-invented the entire DC universe. so…. yeah.