Alexa Chung is a model, TV host, clothing designer and all-around “it” girl for the indie-slacker-fashionista gals out there, myself included. Her effortless style, raspy voice and pert British accent have set her apart over recent years, and landed her a leading spot as Madewell’s spokesmodel. Chung has blogs-upon-blogs dedicated to her, posting photos of her from anywhere on the Internet one might dig them up, but one posted on Instagram this weekend stirred up some controversy. Apparently the model, idolized for her boyish figure, is now too thin, to the point of “thinspo.” See the questionable photo after the cut.
After incurring some pretty nasty responses, mainly the petty and ignorant kind, Alexa responded the way any adult would — see her response at the bottom:
I think Alexa’s response was pretty measured — I appreciate that she says “People are different sizes” because that’s the bottom line. The girls posting nasty responses to her photo (see some more in the slideshow) are freaked out because that’s not what they’re used to seeing, either on themselves or on most people. That doesn’t, however, mean that it’s wrong. I’ve caught flack my whole life, not only for being thin and boyish, but also for gaining weight any time I did. While I feel like no one would walk up to a girl and say, “Your boobs are too big” or “You’ve got muffin-tops,” people do feel comfortable commenting on a thin person’s weight, as if they’re immune to criticism because they’re thin. It’s a strange phenomenon I’ve observed a lot in my life. Having been called anorexic more than a few times over the years, I totally understand why Alexa would make her account private after these comments. In my opinion, she’s right; we’re all different, and the Internet’s anonymity might give people the right to their opinion, but it unfortunately opens the floodgates for outspoken ignorance, too. Good for her for nipping it in the bud.
Do you disagree? Is Alexa too thin?




guest
I don’t know whether or not she’s too thin, but I don’t think the picture qualifies as thinspo. Just because she happens to be very skinny doesn’t make every picture she takes of herself thinspo.
guest
@cryholy – I totally agree!
daisy / 647 posts
God forbid her to be thin!
It’s really annoying to see people bash thin people for being thin, or for others to bash people for being curvy. People need to get over it and realize that not everyone is the same, and that the many different body shapes out there are beautiful.
guest
God, people are so fucking mean. So now if a skinny person takes a picture of herself it is automatically thinspo? Give me a BREAK. I would have made my account private too. And I like how some people are like “You look gross” and some people are like “Omg I’m worried about you, you’re too skinny.” Both are assuming she has some sort of health problem and chances are she doesn’t. The bottom line is: leave people alone!!
guest
Can I ask a question?
I see some defensiveness about the whole “thinspo” thing.
Eating disorders do kill…ten percent of the people who have them will die as a direct result of them. Yes, some people are very thin organically…but that represents what percentage of the thinspo world? I see people more than willing to jump all over fat people about the “health issue” angle…so why are you expected to ignore it in the thinspo community?
I’m not “hating”. I’m not commenting on the look…I’m wondering why in one place the same action is “loving concern”, but in the other it’s being a bitchy hater?
orchid / 128 posts
I agree with most of this, except for the “While I feel like no one would walk up to a girl and say, “Your boobs are too big” or “You’ve got muffin-tops,” peopledo feel comfortable commenting on a thin person’s weight, as if they’re immune to criticism because they’re thin.” People WILL comfortably call others out publicly for being fat. Whenever a star is criticized for being thin, it gets turned into a body policing olympics of thinner and heavier people being put against one another insisting that they have it worse. I don’t think fat or skinny is the problem; it’s the widely-held idea that women’s bodies are public property to be viewed and critiqued freely.
guest
@galadrial@xanga - she just posted a photo of herself. She should be able to do that without people bashing her for being too skinny. It’s just an Instagram photo of her and a friend. She should be able to upload that without being told “ew”.
sunflower / 321 posts
@daydreams_nightmares@xanga - yeah, it’s her mom no less! we should be saying “aw” not “ew”
guest
@galadrial@xanga - I get what you are saying but not all thin people are part of the “thinspo” community…
guest
@daydreams_nightmares@xanga - And I did not say “ewwwwwwwwww”. I was reading the replies. This is a touchy subject…or so I have noticed.
guest
@voicimessecrets@xanga - YES.
guest
@kackie - haha is it? oops!
guest
@galadrial@xanga - I never said you did…the girl who commented on the photo in the article did. She said “ew, she’s so skinny it’s gross” – if I posted a photo of me and someone said that I’d be pretty upset.
guest
Well, she looks like she IS underweight, but that’s her concern, not ours.
guest
well she looks pretty thin to me, but as I already said when tumblr decided to forbid thinspos…thin women, even when they actually do suffer from anorexia, should not be forbidden to show pictures of themselves. Do you want them to not go to pubic places too? Showing a picture of yourself doesn’t mean you glamourize anorexia and being thin doesn’t mean you think fat people are ugly.
guest
it’s not a good idea to be born a woman in this world. if you’re too thin, you’re anorexic – or worse, you’re encouraging people to be anorexic just by taking a photograph of yourself with what appears to be your mum. if you’re fat, you have no self control and you’re a pig. you must be absolutely average, to the tee… at which point we’ll say you’re boring and look like all the rest.
guest
as a person diagnosed with an eating disorder, I think its awful that people would just automatically categorize alexa as supporting “thinspo” or being anorexic. I think she looks fine in my opinion and that people shouldn’t judge. period. I’m not saying any of you are judging, I see your points but I think that we shouldn’t judge people on their size.
guest
@under_the_carpet@xanga - How many of those thinspo fans/makers are actually making pictures of themselves and showing them on their blogs? Aren’t they just posting pictures or thin celebrities/models or stealing pictures from thin bloggers for inspiration?
guest
She’s thinner than she use to be, but I think a lot of people have weight that fluctuates. I do think it’s funny that you think fat people don’t get walked up to and criticized as much as thin people do. I have friends of all sizes- the boney ones get told they’re lucky, the fat ones get made fun of.
guest
You see that jean dress she’s wearing?
I OWN IT! Okay. Excitement over. (Isn’t it just really awesome to see other people wearing the clothing you have? I LOVE IT!)I think she’s beautiful and haters gonna hate.
guest
Attacking any body size is disgusting to me. It just doesn’t sit right. All bodies are beautiful and should be accepted. (: Now, for the reason I clicked the article, I love that jacket in the first photo. Stunning!
guest
wow. story of my life. I’m thin and I took appetite stimulants because I was depressed over all the ignorant and fucked up comments I got about being thin. And for some “special” people who want to go into healthcare who wanted to hate on me and call me anorexic when I was not/am not- fuck you you ignorant piece of shit. But that’s the angry teen inside of me talking. I’m so happy for Alexa Chung that she was adult about it. I would’ve flipped out. Like it’s sooo true. People are such different sizes and everyone has their preferences. Get your god damn head out of your ass and make some fucking friends or just I dont know, LOOK AROUND. not every super skinny girl is anorexic, and I could be a hater and start talking shit about fat girls who are self-conscience and want to talk shit about those who are thin, but there’s nothing I can say that can change their ignorance. Yes, eating disorders are terrible and they kill and nobody should have to go through that. But how about you stop taking it upon yourself to tell other people that they look too skinny or too fat just in case they’re NATURAL size makes other people get an eating disorder.
it’s just irritating.
guest
Her reaction was very tactful.