Why Interacting with a Woman Can Leave Men ‘Cognitively Impaired’… this is the actual title of an article in Scientific American! More from the article here:
Researchers have begun to explore the cognitive impairment that men experience before and after interacting with women. A 2009 study demonstrated that after a short interaction with an attractive woman, men experienced a decline in mental performance. A more recent study suggests that this cognitive impairment takes hold even when men simply anticipate interacting with a woman who they know very little about.
My first thought was that this was probably a simplistic reductionist article written by some uneducated blogger (such as myself). But it turns out that article was written by Daisy Grewal who “received her PhD in social psychology from Yale University. She is a researcher at the Stanford School of Medicine, where she investigates how stereotypes affect the careers of women and minority scientists.”
Wow ok, let’s dig in a bit:
[After taking a test of cognitive function], participants in Nauts’ study were asked … to read out loud a number of Dutch words while sitting in front of a webcam. The experimenters told them that during this “lip reading task” an observer would watch them over the webcam. The observer was given either a common male or female name.
Participants were led to believe that this person would see them over the web cam, but they would not be able to interact with the person. No pictures or other identifying information were provided about the observer—all the participants knew was his or her name. After the lip reading task, the participants took another [test of cognitive function]. Women’s performance on the second test did not differ, regardless of the gender of their observer.
However men who thought a woman was observing them ended up performing worse on the second test. This cognitive impairment occurred even though the men had not interacted with the female observer.
The scientists had a theory for what caused the cognitive impairment: “Although the studies on their own don’t offer any concrete explanations, Nauts and her colleagues think that the reason may have something to do with men being more strongly attuned to potential mating opportunities. Since all of their participants were both heterosexual and young, they might have been thinking about whether the woman might be a potential date.”
We’d love to hear from our readers on this. Ladies, do you ever notice that men are cognitively impaired by the potential to mate with you? Guys, do you ever get distracted by potential mating opportunities and become cognitively impaired?
guest
Big surprise, a woman who believes men only think with their penises, the surprise was that she needed a PHD to come up with that theory.
guest
Neurosexism — A lot of the authors research for these books (female and male brain, respectively) is not very well backed. It’s interesting to be sure, but take it for what it is. A potential piece to a much larger puzzle.
rose / 948 posts
we’re quite complicated
guest
or men don’t know how to read Dutch as well as women in the study, so they were self conscious of their Dutch reading skills, not because they were insecure that a potential hottie was watching them
guest
@lorelei@xanga - Thank goodness someone said this! You’re right, it’s very true that there isn’t enough support for these researches. I read Daisy Grewal’s “The Female Brain” and it was alright to an extent. She only uses examples that support her claim; however, she uses her experiences with her clients and some biological facts to present her points. I feel she should have used more outside research to go along the examples of her past sessions with her clients.
Also, there was a significant amount of critics stating that a lot of the “research” she uses actually contradict her points or meant something else. Either way, it’s up to the reader to decide whether they should take it or leave it in terms of her work.
guest
now I know why a certain Xangan pretended to be a young athletic woman har har.
guest
also…how unscientific of me…but I just don’t like these gender study tests. I mean what are they good for other than bias and prejudices? The minorities (here men who don’t care) are always “dragged into the dirt”. Also, the cognitive impairment was probably not significant at all…it’s not like men lose all their senses when they see a woman.
peony / 1 posts
This needs much more research.I am unable to function in the presence of a sexually attractive female.
Unattractive females cause no cognitive impairment in me whatsoever.