Urban Outfitters has been receiving some serious backlash concerning their new St. Patrick’s Day t-shirts. C’mon guys. Can’t we all just wear a plain green shirt and get along?
The clothing store recently stocked their shelves with a slew of items in honor of the holiday, and the Irish and Irish-American communities aren’t exactly… thrilled, shall we say, with the selection. In fact, they’ve asked UO to stop selling the pieces (pictured above), stating that they “depicted severe and negative stereotypes” and promoted “binge drinking”. Well, kinda.
But here’s the thing: St. Patrick’s Day is a pretty popular drinking holiday, what with $1 green beer specials (so appetizing) and the parade and, well, we kind of always associated the holiday with drinking too. Not to mention the majority of the celebrations of said holiday aren’t exactly exclusively Irish affairs anymore, nor do they involve attending church services (St. Patty’s Day is a Catholic commemoration.). All races, nationalities, and creeds make merry on March 17th, so perhaps Urban was just generalizing here, rather than singling out the Irish community. We’re trying to give them some benefit of the doubt.
But we can see, too, where offense might be taken, especially to the “Kiss me, I’m drunk, or Irish, or whatever” t-shirt, which seems to suggest that being drunk and Irish are synonymous with each other. Probably not the best choice in wording, and wording is everything. Better luck next time, Urban. Still love your bangin’ sale section. (via Huffington Post)
What do you Lovelies think? Is the apparel in bad taste or would you rock it?
guest
I think if it were a shirt about a non-white group, everyone would be pissed.
guest
It’s in bad taste. There are more tasteful and original ways to represent the Irish/Irish American culture without using the shock value of a stereotype.
guest
Given my Irish heritage, I definitely think less of UO for these t-shirts/gear. However, they can say whatever they want — it just means I’m not going to patronize them.
daisy / 617 posts
I think people are just entirely too sensitive these days. No matter what any company is going to put out, some group will make a stink about it.
guest
I’m no fan of Urban Outfitters, but I’ve seen plenty of other stores sell similar things for St. Patty’s Day. I’m Irish myself, and I don’t have a problem with it.
guest
Really? I would buy this shirt, and I’m glad my Irish friends have their heads out of their asses far enough to appreciate the humor. And if I sound insensitive, I really don’t care.
guest
Oh, please. I know plenty of stores who sell t-shirts etc. saying “Kiss me, I’m Irish” for St. Patrick’s day and I’ve never heard of anyone kick up a fuss over it before. Maybe Europe is just less sensitive :-/
cherry blossom / 47 posts
I love St Patrick’s Day! I’m Irish and I think I would rock something like this.. I mean why not? If you don’t like it, don’t buy it
sunflower / 413 posts
Ahhhh I want that Irish Yoga hat! And this does not offend me at all. I like how most of the commenters who are Irish (like myself) didn’t get upset. Irish people know the heritage is related to getting wasted and accept it.
guest
To me, that shirt isn’t making being drunk and being Irish synonymous. More like, “Kiss me for any reason you feel” lol. Oh people will get offended by anything.
guest
@daydreams_nightmares@xanga - kiss me i’m irish is entirely different from saying “kiss me, i’m drunk, or irish or whatever” which implies that being irish is synonymous with being drunk/a drunk/an alcoholic.
@WaitingToShrug@xanga - i very much agree. i think racism and ethnic stereotyping of ANY kind is entirely inappropriate and hateful and find it very frustrating that because i’m white, i’m only allowed to fight against racism against others, not my own race/ethnicity.
i’m primarily of irish heritage and i find this very offensive. they can say whatever they want since it’s a free country, but i won’t be buying their crap if they’re going to promote binge drinking and perpetuate the stereotype that only irish people are the ones who abuse alcohol.
daffodil / 1615 posts
Irish people would stop getting so worked up over tee-shirts.
guest
I can definitely see how the pictured items are offensive. It stereotypes people of Irish heritage as drunks. If the people being targeted are bothered by it and don’t see it as “good fun” since the intent of the items are to stereotype no question, then they shouldn’t be accused of being too sensitive.
guest
Seriously people shouldn’t be upset if this is how they act on st pattys day. I think it’s harmless humor
guest
“St. Paddy’s.” Patty is female, Paddy is male.
guest
They do this on purpose so you stupid people will talk about how heinous the designs are. PUBLICITY.
guest
I mean it’s whatever. Is any Irish group offended by the shirts? Because if not, then it is not really the place of anyone else to be upset. I am part Irish and I find the shirt funny. We get made fun of for being drunks. I’m also part black and if it were a shirt about fried chicken I would still think it was funny. But that’s just me.
guest
I think it would be one thing if it were something promoting violence against irish people, but it is just a stereotype that people have not made a big hoopla about when jokes get made about it. Now that it is on a t-shirt everyone is pissed.
guest
@corporatecrow@xanga - They have those over here too, and people don’t get all offended about it. I just think people get all up in arms about really pointless things these days – if you want something to be offended about, focus on something important – war, poverty, injustice, poor education or whatever, not a random t-shirt.
guest
@Digital_Angel21@xanga - but what to people do on St. Patrick’s day? Drink cheap beer and get drunk – I don’t see anyone getting offended by that, but because it’s in print on a t-shirt, it’s suddenly offensive and encouraging stereotypes? You can’t have it both ways. You can’t go out, drink and encourage your own stereotype then complain when commercial companies pick up on it.
guest
stupid. not surprised from urban outfitters. irish aren’t as badly stereotyped in america as in europe though… which doesn’t excuse it. but i find the navajo nation (the real navajo people) sueing urban outfitters much more interesting.
clarly, no one from navajo nation is designing their products but they label it as such using the navajo nation name, in clear violation of the indian arts and crafts act. native americans continue to be the most misrepresented, with economic and health disparities from other social groups that are staggering. to use culturally appropriate them for monetary gain or for a trend is disgusting.http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/46574519/ns/business-retail/#.T1SvtYePWSr
guest
I wouldn’t wear it. To me, they’re playing on the stereotype that the Irish are just a bunch of drunks. Would I be pissed off if someone else bought and wore it? No. If they want to look like an ignorant racist, then that’s their prerogative.
guest
@corporatecrow@xanga - LOL, you’re the only one that agrees with me.
You know that everyone got all up in arms about the Navajo thing.
My feeling is, it’s either okay to make fun of all cultures, or it’s not okay to make fun of any. If this were about Juneteenth, it would not be okay with anyone.
orchid / 128 posts
I think “Kiss Me, I’m Drunk” is disturbing enough for the shirt to be pulled.
guest
@daydreams_nightmares@xanga - I feel like the only people who “embrace” the stereotype are those that are very detached from their Irish heritage and really only bring up that they are Irish when talking about drinking. On St. Patrick’s Day, people get drunk regardless if they are Irish or not because it’s seen as just a holiday to get drunk here in the US. Just because people decide to turn an Irish holiday (and a religious one at that) into a day to get drunk doesn’t mean they can also start stereotyping Irish and Irish-Americans as “drunks”.
As I said, if none of the heritage groups were saying anything, then it wouldn’t matter. But clearly it does to them. Therefore the products need to be pulled.
guest
@Digital_Angel21@xanga - I just don’t think you can pull things off the shelf because someone’s offended. You’ll always offend someone somehow – but if you don’t like something, vote with your feet – don’t shop their and encourage your friends to do the same….but getting a company to pull their products because you’re upset is ridiculous in my opinion.
However, maybe it’s just different here. I mean, I live in England and loads of places sell things with these slogans on, and I’ve never seen anyone get offended by it – all the Irish people I know embrace their stereotype or at least know to laugh about it. Those t-shirts aren’t intended to be offensive, they’re just for fun. People need to lighten up a little.
guest
Lol oh, come on. The holiday promotes binge drinking! I actually like the shirt. Why are humans so damn sensitive?
@daydreams_nightmares@xanga - This!