Oh, Twilight Series, it’s so easy to analyze and dissect. Really, it is. Despite protests from true fans that the books were never meant to be analyzed and that Stephanie Meyers herself has proclaimed they have no “point” or “message,” the books are just begging to be critically analyzed. Whether you agree with that or not, you have to admit, the books (and movies) have some seriously creepy moments — and not just average, “well that’s weird” creepy, but horror movie creepy. Keep reading to find out the top three creepiest moments from Twilight.
It’s every girl’s dream to wake up from her wedding night bruised and bloodied and with no recollection of what happened, right? Right? Um, no, Stephanie Meyers, NO. The justifications I hear for this creeptacular wedding night are honestly the most ridiculous things I’ve ever heard and they don’t actually counter the assertion that: waking up with no memory of having sex with your new husband, but you’re bruised, bloody, and sore isn’t romantic or sweet or something you ask for. That’s rape. That is straight up rape. It doesn’t matter if she just married him, or if she “wanted it.” It’s creepy and weird. And while sex can be weird, it shouldn’t be that violent and you should have clear memories of it. The last book of the series bothered me more than any other and really cemented, in my view, the fact that every single man in the book is abusive in one way or another.
Don’t even get me started on the fact that Bella effectively wakes up pregnant. Creepy overload.
He’s climbing in yo’ windows, he’s snatching yo’ babies up. And imprinting on them.
Just writing the phrase “Jacob imprints on a baby” caused a shiver to run down my spine. Seriously, so creepy. In case you don’t know, “imprinting” is a response of shape-shifters when they find their soulmate; they lose all affection and feelings for others and only focus on one another. So, in short, Jacob falls in love with a baby and somehow it magically falls in love with him because babies totally have those kind of complex feelings. If someone ever looked at my baby and admitted to “imprinting on it,” I would call the cops the second they turned their backs. And then Renesmee (oh my dear that name) “ages rapidly,” so even though she’s only seven, she totally looks 17, so it’s OK! I am so creeped out.
Readers, what do you think? What’s the creepiest moment from Twilight for you?
guest
i’ve never read twilight, but this has amused me greatly
guest
I’ve read the books, but haven’t seen all the movies out. I didn’t think the books were anything that great anyway, and yeah, some moments were a little creepy.
guest
i never read the books and watch the movies for laughs.
and this post really made me laugh.
guest
To be fair, it was made pretty clear that she remembered the sex, Meyer was just trying not to go into detail because these books are written for tween girls, so she kept it vague. Edward does plenty of creepy, unacceptable things to complain about, without having to make things up. He did not rape her. She definitely wanted to have sex (even after being warned repeatedly that it would be dangerous and she could potentially die), especially the second time, she actually begged for it (barf). Now the bruising (there was no blood), that’s weird, and maybe takes S&M a little too far, but again, considering she pleaded with Edward for more just a few nights later, it clearly wasn’t non-consensual. She made a stupid decision, yes, but it was informed and it was her decision. Edward is a creepy, abusive stalker, but Bella eats it up. The creepiest part about his behavior, imho, is that she actually likes it.
Honestly, if this were my list, I think I would replace the wedding night with the parts of Eclipse where he removes the engine from her truck or has Alice kidnap her to prevent her from seeing Jacob. The fact that she would continue to stay with a man who tries to control her like that is extremely creepy.
peony / 3 posts
he’s climbin’ in yo windows,
he’s snatchin’ yo people up, tryin’ to rape ‘em so ya need to hide yo kids, hide yo wife,
hide yo kids, hide yo wife,
hide yo kids, hide yo wife
and hide yo husband becuz they rapin’ e’rrbody out here.You don’t have to come and confess
We’re looking’ for you
we gon find you we gon find you run and tell that homeboy
And the beginning sounds like Edward a bit no?
Love the Bed Intruder song reference! Its stuck in my head!
guest
I think that even creepier than any of this is that Disney cartoon Beauty and the Beast(iality) where the lovely female falls for a creature that is sort of a Dog, a buffalo and a lion all swirled together. Disney couldn’t use an animation of just some really ugly, nasty REAL guy that you might see in Walmart because that would gross the female audience out. But show a petite lady falling for what is the equivalent of a buffalo / dog combo special and everyone is like “Awww. How sweet.” CREEPY.
But … I did know a woman who confessed to having fantasies about being ravaged by huge werewolves. So, I guess that I can see why gals might go for the buffalo / dog combo special.
guest
The amusement I got from this post is the first thing Twilight has ever been useful for, imo.
guest
@BinarySearch@xanga - honestly, the beast is more attractive to me than he is once he turns back into the prince. fabio anyone?
guest
I agree with you! Except that she remembered the sex. I just watched the movie and livetweeted it’s suckness. It was so much fun. And she definitely remembered the sex.
cherry blossom / 30 posts
I loved #1. My fiance and I gave the first movie a shot and when it got to that part he freaked out. To this day, he still criticizes Stephanie Meyer as the “creeper promoting unhealthy teenage relationships.” By the time we got to the sparkling, he was done.
I love your point in #3 too (she looks 17 so it’s totally ok). Um, I don’t know Jacob’s age at that part in the book but last time I checked 18 was the legal age for consent…
guest
LMAO. this really made me laugh, very interesting — ive never read the books but have watched the movies.
guest
This Twilight hate is getting just as old as the Twi-hards! If you don’t like the stuff don’t fucking watch it or read it. Simple as that god damnit.
People are fucking stupid!
guest
@corporatecrow@xanga - Haha I agree. His real body/face/look just isn’t very attractive.
I remember when the first movie came out I used to argue with everyone I knew who would say edward was so romantic mainly with the sneaking in her room and watching her sleep thing. That part over everything else reaaaaallly bugged me. Especially because people’s general defenses for that scene were stupid things like “Well he’s a vampire so it’s ok.” Though it’s just an exaggeration of Peter Pan peeking on Wendy I guess. Steph is a horrible writer though…
rose / 786 posts
I read the books just to see what all of the hype was about, and lets just say I wasted a few weeks of my life. And now I’ve seen the first and the 3rd movie, just because one of my friends wants to see it. I’m not going to lie, I was interested in seeing it too, but not for the same reason. And again. a few hours of my life wasted….
guest
When I wake up next to a guy I’m with, sometimes I stare at them while they sleep. I guess I’m creepy…
rose / 791 posts
@Digital_Angel21@xanga - but he was in the room watching her sleep without her knowing!! THAT’s creepy, lol.
guest
I definitely thought these were the 3 creepiest moments too lol.
guest
@BinarySearch@xanga - I just finished choking from laughter, your comment is frigging hysterical. I always thought of a buffalo/ lion type thing too. lol
guest
Honestly, the part with Renesmee. He imprints on her, that means that he is whatever she needs at that point in time. So when she is a baby or a little girl he is her protector and her best friend. It is not until she gets older that he will become something else. Although I do agree that the fact that she is actually a little kid but looks and acts 17 (Although mentally and maturity wise she will be as well since she grows in those ways as well just as quickly), is slightly creepy.
guest
If she “straight up wanted it” then it wasn’t rape. Just because it was violent doesn’t make it a crime. Do you know what rape is?
guest
Yeah, he has some creepy moments. But I don’t think he raped her on the wedding night…
guest
No means yes!
I need to ask my boo to watch me sleep. . . every night. That is SUPER hott!
sunflower / 393 posts
The imprinting on the baby was what really threw me off in the books. I never thought they were much for literary minds, but they were sort of a guilty pleasure until that moment. I liked Jacob because he didn’t come off as a pedo. Then he fell in love with baby what’s-her-face and it was all downhill for his character from there.
guest
God, get over yourself, lol
1) yeah, it’s kinda creepy, I’ll give you that
2) Come on! Seriously? she remembered it. she wasn’t bloody. it was HER decision. she was not raped.
3) It’s not like he is going to make a move or anything. i can’t quote it, but I’m pretty sure he said that when you imprint on someone, you’s be anything they want you to be. friend, brother, boyfriend, father-figure, anything. it’s really not that creepy.
guest
i know right! thank you for saying this.
guest
incredibly creepy. my 11-year-old sister wants to read the books and I told her the only way she could is if I read them with her (like x amount of chapters by this date) and we sat down and had talks about why relationships like that are ABUSIVE and NOT OKAY.
guest
Not a fan of Twilight but I read the books, and to be fair, imprinting doesn’t always mean falling in love. When you imprint it can mean love, friendship, father figure, brother, etc. It obviously is not creepy if you read the books and have an IQ higher than a 5 year old.
guest
he ripped a baby out of bella’s womb. with his teeth.
and then there was a fountain of blood.
guest
Edward is seriously like…the poster boy for an abusive boyfriend.
guest
i agree with @TheVoiletVixen@xanga.
1. a little creepy, yeah. i don’t think it’s extremely creepy, though. it’s not like he was going to hurt her or anything. he could have done worse.
2. the definition of rape is that it’s not consensual. she wanted it, so it was not rape. and she wasn’t bloodied, only bruised because he was so much stronger than she was. and she did remember it. i don’t know where you got that she didn’t.
3. one of the downfalls of the english language is that there is only one word for love. when renesmee is a baby, jacob in no way loves her romantically. as mentioned in other comments, jacob becomes what she needs at that stage in her life and the relationship will only become romantic when she’s older.
guest
@raspberryjade@xanga - i am glad you’re not going to let her read the books on their own; they are a bit mature for an 11-year-old. but how is edward abusive?
@xFgtxRainbowx@xanga - how so?
guest
@danaenicole@xanga - While he is not overtly physically abusive, he definitely is abusive. He emotionally abuses her. He talks down to her constantly and treats her like an idiot. He intimidates her constantly. How many times—in just the first book alone—was Bella afraid of Edward,
afraid to look at him, afraid of what his reaction might be? How many times did she attempt to sneak around and do something behind his back because she knew it would anger him? Coercion and threats are one of the signs of abuse as well. All his talk of suicide and hating himself is a problem. When you’re in a relationship, and the other person talks about killing themselves if you’re gone, that’s abuse. He also holds power over her constantly. He makes all the decisions, and she is forced to go along. How many times has she not wanted to do something, and yet he forces her physically? He made her leave when James was coming, even though she didn’t want to. At one point, he literally drags her into his car. Which also ties into Isolation. He takes the battery out of her truck so she can’t visit Jacob. He has Alice watch her when he is away. He also stalked her. Someone showing up in your room to watch you sleep at night is stalking. Most definitely. http://www.squidoo.com/cullenabuse if you want to read more in depth.
orchid / 164 posts
meh, hating on twilight is soo overdone that even anything resembling wit doesn’t really carry that much with me anymore.. i read the books, lots of teenaged and college aged girls read the books, we know they’re over-the-top cheesy, but seriously.. just let it go already. #1, she wasn’t all bruised and bloody and didn’t remember anything — stephanie meyer is pretty religious and wouldn’t write too much detail about a sex scene. just chill out about this already. its old.
orchid / 164 posts
@xFgtxRainbowx@xanga - i think she was supposed to be afraid of him because he was a vampire, not because he was going to beat her or something. and yes, i know emotional abuse, blahblah.. i just think setphanie meyer is a not so great writer trying to be sexy-scary-vampy and lovey dovey at the same time but just misses the mark and it turns out seeming like abuse if you look way too far into it. bella’s just a weak character.. i think we all realize that by now. as for the effect it has on young children, idk, i’m hoping that kids aren’t reading this until they’re like, 14+ and at that point, hopefully they know the difference between fiction/fantasy and real life. if not, setphanie meyer isnt going to be the deciding force for teens to be like “ok its ok to let my boyfriend scare me like this,” … she’s not that convincing of a writer.
guest
I think what’s pathetic is that you’re no fan of Twilight yet you waste your time reading them. If you really don’t like them stop wasting your time reading them. Just saying.
guest
@xjadersx@xanga - People use their supposed contempt of twilight to try to prove to the people of the interwebz that they iz smart! It’s the cool thing to do, you didn’t know?
guest
For as much as everyone hates Twilight, we sure do talk about it a lot. I mean… when I get annoyed by things, and/or hate them I tend to not talk about them.
So how about we find new topics to talk about Lovelyish writers?
guest
& I never once read in the book where she doesn’t remember her wedding night… The book wasn’t a Harlequin romance novel, it couldn’t go into detail about how he thrust his gigantic shaft in her. I mean come on now guys…
guest
@Mrs_FoodLover@xanga - his gigantic cold hard shaft. …just saying…LOL.
rose / 812 posts
For somebody who hates the books so much, you and the rest of the haters sure to talk about it a lot. I’m sure 95% of the haters have never read the books either, which is hilarious to me. I could explain how all of your assumptions are wrong but I doubt you care.
guest
@citadel_of_stars@xanga - thank you for that, lol.
also, you’re analyzing this way too much. i’m still surprised that considering how much people HATE twilight they just can’t stop talking about it. you’re obsessed with hating it and you’re analyzing and nitpicking and honestly i think that’s MUCH MUCH WORSE than being a fan of the books.
the watching her sleep is a bit creepy, but he did NOT rape her and like citadel said, if you’d read, imprinting doesn’t mean he’s sexually attracted to her and wants to bone her.
STOP OBSESSING PEOPLE, IT’S ANNOYING AS FUCK TO SEE ALL THESE TWILIGHT HATE POSTS.
guest
@grizzlybearr@xanga - LOL, you are awesome!
guest
@UnconventionalButterfly@xanga - hey we wrote close to the same thing! lol.
guest
@Mrs_FoodLover@xanga - lol i couldn’t resist! we’ve got to be correct when talking about a vampire’s shaft, ya know? hahahaha. and i guess lovelyish could go back to talking about hating miley cyrus? it seems a lot of hate goes on on this site.
rose / 812 posts
@grizzlybearr@xanga - Wooo! Hahaha
orchid / 127 posts
@xjadersx@xanga - i agree.
i read the last two books after harshly judging it and decided that while not really a great book it wasn’t horrible either. nothing special. but it’s better to read than to not read at all.
guest
This is hillarriouss. I am still not interested in seeing the Twilight series lol
guest
@BinarySearch@xanga - Lmfao, the fact you pointed out he looks like a buffalo just made my day. Never thought of that before. That is kind of weird, but Beauty and the Beast is still 290389472x better than Twilight any day!
sunflower / 332 posts
LMAO!!! Waking up bruised and not remembering the night you had sex is really effed up! I think that Stephenie Meyer likes creepy….I mean if I woke up with bruises and blood, I wouldn’t be happy about it, I would be freaked out! Especially if I don’t remember having sex! R-A-P-E
guest
What was creepy and disturbing to me is vampire’s sparkling? seriously!!! Vampires do not sparkle…they freaking burn to death!!! (UGH!!! Twilight just totally ruined the reputation of vampires…) I couldn’t get past that and the whole staring thing that you mentioned in part 1 (I couldn’t even finish the first movie and didn’t bother with the rest…though sounds like it gets even creepier so I’m glad I didn’t waste my time hoping it would redeem the vampire reputation)…
guest
WHAT. the fuck.
Sounds stoooopid.
guest
I’ve only read the first book.
Okay so it’s a little on the weird-o side but it’s not THAT bad. I kind of felt like you blew it a little out of proportion, but I suppose other people interpret things differently.
guest
omg! hahaha!!! i can’t believe you actually read through all the books. i couldn’t even get past the 1st chapter of the first one. ugh.
guest
@grizzlybearr@xanga - twilight’s gay
guest
@grizzlybearr@xanga - twilight’s gay
guest
You know its really funny from both sides. All the people complaining about how it’s annoying all this Twilight hate and why waste your time, why are you wasting your time hating on their opinions it could be perceived as just as annoying. I for one read the Twilight books right when they came out and I couldn’t stand them. That is my opinion just like people who like them have their own opinion. Both sides really need to stop acting holier than though. We all have opinions because we’re all individual people, but really people need to have more respect for each other because it’s getting a bit ridiculous.
guest
@dicemn7@xanga - They could have at least made the sparkling without the awful sound effects haha.
Yes, Edward has some very creepy moments and you picked some very good creepy points, though I’m not sure I agree with the wedding one entirely.
I sure as hell wouldn’t want to be watched when I sleep.
guest
I love Twilight posts! I’ve never read the books, but I love reading the impassioned comments. They’re funny because in the end everyone agrees that the books are silly and not really of literary consequence… but they get so angry over other people loving/hating them! Keep ‘em coming, Lovelyish!
guest
LOL this is hilarious. lol lol lol lol