Twilight has become so prevalent in our society today that people have actually begun using it as an excuse for their behavior. Apparently, it’s normal now to just say “I blame Twilight” when things go wrong or when you want to do something outside of the norm. Here are four specific things that Twilight has been blamed for since the phenomena began.
During the opening weekend of Breaking Dawn, Illinois police arrested Olivia Christina Ornelas, an 18-year-old girl for driving under the influence after crashing her car. These two seemingly unrelated facts became incredibly relevant when Ornelas blamed her intoxication and crashing her car on her boyfriend for not taking her to see the newest Twilight film that night like he promised. Huffington Post reported that she was reportedly very upset when she explained this to the police, who then charged her with driving under the influence and unlawful consumption of alcohol by a minor.
Above was just the first incident that I noticed someone blaming on Twilight. After intense Internet research, I discovered a lot more, including one about two runaway kids back in June ’09. According to The Examiner, two 13-year-old girls skipped school and set up an overnight camp in the woods of Gloucester due to inspiration from series.
The girls left letters and notes under their pillows and in friend’s lockers to explain why they had run away — and it was these letters that implicated Twilight involvement. Apparently, parts of the notes to friends were copied word for word from a letter in the fourth Twilight book, Breaking Dawn.
“The letters followed the same story line where they said they had to get away because they were endangering people by staying around and that the reason would become apparent to people later,” said Rockfort police Sergeant Schmink, who was familiar with the series because of his daughters.
The letters under their pillows also made specific references to characters in the books. Pamela, one of the girls, even made the “a” in her signature incorporate two fangs with blood dripping from them.
These clues and the missing camping supplies eventually allowed police to find the girls in the woods.
“The reason these kids left wasn’t drugs or alcohol, they weren’t lured out of the house by a predator and there wasn’t a bad family environment,” Schmink said. Twilight was the only reason these girls left home. Who knew a book could be so powerful?
A while ago there was a highly publicized biting epidemic that also blamed Twilight. Teen couples had begun biting each other as a sign of affection, sometimes even biting hard enough to draw blood.
“For me, biting is the way to show affection toward the other person and to just get a crazy adrenaline rush and not so much to mark territory or to show I belong to something, but just to show the other person I care and there’s a deeper sense of affection,” Michael Kaplor, 16, told Good Morning America in July ’09. The teens drew blood to feel powerful, getting an adrenaline rush from the experience.
The problem with this trend is that biting can lead to disease. The bites can become infected and can spread blood diseases like hepatitis, syphilis and HIV.
The connection was made to Twilight when teenagers started getting tattoos of bite marks. It was the first indication that the kids weren’t taking hickeys too far, but were actually mimicking this prominent part of pop culture.
The last thing people often blame Twilight for that I feel the need to mention in this post is the ending of relationships, specifically divorce.
I’ve heard from a lot of people that women will actually break up with boyfriends or divorce husbands because they aren’t as perfect as Edward Cullen. Women, especially Twi-Moms. Specifically, one of readers commented on a post about Twi-Moms and said that one wife felt that she deserved to have two men vying for her attention like Jacob and Edward do in the books.
The Twilight books are highly romanticized and very fairytale-like in that Bella gets a knight in shining armor that puts their love above all else. This is something that every girl wishes for in a relationship, but it’s also very improbable. Unfortunately, Twilight seems to have raised expectations and with these expectations, it has also raised divorce rates.
Have/Would you ever blamed anything on this series? What do you think of these incidences? What else do people blame on Twilight?
guest
IMO, the only thing that Twilight is guilty of is shitty literature.
guest
If you’re going to break up with someone because he doesn’t sneak into your room at night and watch you sleep (or because two men aren’t fighting over you like a piece of meat) you should probably blame Twilight for depriving you of all self-respect and common sense.
guest
I blame Twilight for the brain hemmorage the shitty book gave me.
guest
I’m waiting for a Twi-hard to comment on this post. After today, I could use a good laugh.
orchid / 203 posts
not going to lie i like the books and the movies but not to the point where i wish life was like the series. there’s obviously something wrong with people if they get that involved. why blame a book on peoples ignorance. its like they blame video games saying it’ll make children be violent. people need to be taught whats real and fiction
guest
@Ashley Nicole Anders@facebook - @MiriamBeth@xanga - This.
guest
@rosertot_love@xanga - But mostly this!
orchid / 174 posts
Seriously, that book didn’t perform those actions, those people did. I hate it when people can’t take responsibility for their own behavior and the consequences of it. If you’re basing your life off of a work of fiction there’s something wrong with you, the fault doesn’t lie with the work of fiction you’re wrongly trying to mimic. Ugh. I love the Twilight series, it’s a great fictitious concept and there are even parts of it that I can relate to, but I would never base my life off of it. It’s FICTION for chrissakes! I don’t, however, like sparkling vampires. I wish she’d left that part out.
Still, it didn’t change or skew my life perceptions. *sigh* These people need help.
guest
I actually like the Twilight series and, yes, I am a Twi-mom. And so what? It was a fun read, nothing more or less. Some people take it way… too… seriously — those whom are loving it and hating it.
guest
meh, people do dumb things for different reasons. you shouldn’t blame a series for a poor choice that you yourself made.
guest
Stupid people are stupid… I got a good laugh though.
guest
LOL LOL LOL!!!
guest
This is not the first time that people have blame their actions on a book/movie/show. There have been cases of murders from people who tried to imitate Dexter from the show of the same name. I highly doubt a TV show would drive them to murder. They probably had the propensity to commit murder before they even saw the show. The show just gave them an “excuse.” Sadly, I doubt this is the first or last time we will see life attempt to imitate art.
guest
@rosertot_love@xanga - ”literature” is too strong a word to be attached to this series, haha.
guest
I don’t know if I should be happy that so many people are reading books to the point that they actually think they are a character (the power of Stephanie Meyer I guess) or I should be worried about women getting divorce over a movie?
I myself am not a fan of the movies because I think compared to so many other books out there, twilight does not deserve the praise (the book AND the movie)
for both, I wouldn’t waste my money on it.
but biting –> rabies!
guest
I love the books way more than the movies but I do like the movies and can’t wait to see the BD! But my husband has actually goofed around before and pretended to bite me and I say, “knock it off.” so just because I am a huge fan, I won’t be stupid either. I just like them. Yes my daughters middle name is Esme (her first name is from “Lord of the Rings and i never watch that now) but my second daughter was named because of “The Sound of Music,” and the tv series, “Lost.” The only thing I wish is that people could live forever…that would be interesting.
guest
hmm. this is so dumb. it’s just a book/film series! people take things way too seriously.
guest
Really? People should really stop blaming others/objects for their actions and take personal responsbility. While I have not read the books, but have seen 3 of the films, they did not cause me to behave in a wacky manner. The books don’t make people do anything, it’s people doing things. Besides, even if the books were poorly written, since it is found in the fiction section of the book store and just take it at face value: ENTERTAINMENT. Let’s not analyze it too deeply, ok? I guess some people can’t tell the difference between fantasy and reality.
guest
@gilly_owens@xanga - THANK YOU!
This is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard! NO ONE forces a person to do anything they do not want to do, unless they are physically going to kill them.
I love the books and the movies and I do not fucking care what others think.
sunflower / 332 posts
@gilly_owens@xanga - Funny thing there…um…there are such things as crazy people.
Those people that mimmic such things from fiction are NOT okay. And that’s the point she’s trying to make in this post, there are people that actually do these things and they blame it on a book. It may not be the book’s fault, but it certainly plays a part in the actions of these people, they can’t take responsibility for their behaviour because in their little world, they think they’re right. That’s already a phsycological problem that’s existed for many many years, it ain’t new. So even though through our eyes we see that the book isn’t to be blamed, in their eyes it’s a whole different story, the book is practically the key that turns them.
guest
Some people are sociopaths or psychopaths with crap like this, taking fiction to be realistic is something Harris and Klebold did. The biggest problem is just that one word; OBSESSION which isn’t sinful but can be very much a life ruining thing if given in to.
guest
@julieyang76@xanga - again translated, obsessed with the fiction in the series. I know what its like, people wanting so badly to live in that world and pretend its real. Yes our society should blame obsession on this one.
guest
@Orlei@xanga - Kind of like Robert Jordan’s fans who read the WoT series and took the whole ‘channeling the one power’ too seriously to the point they asked him, ‘teach us how to weave’!
guest
@stateofhart@datingish - It’s not literature, its fan-fiction turned into a novel and painted up to look like a timeless classic treasure.
sunflower / 397 posts
The stupidity of humans continues to amaze me…
rose / 812 posts
if you leave your SO becuase of a book, there was already something wrong….
guest
@UnconventionalButterfly@xanga - LOL truth~
guest
“A while ago there was a highly publicized biting epidemic that also blamedTwilight. Teen couples had begun biting each other as a sign of affection, sometimes even biting hard enough to draw blood.”
This is funny because it’s actually backwards. In Bram Stokers Dracula the bite marks on the woman’s neck weren’t there to imply her blood had been sucked out, but to imply that she had sex with the vampire.
It would amuse me if things like Twilight influenced more teens to join living vampire religions though.
guest
Why somebody would want 2 guys fighting over her is a mystery to me. All it is is drama and heartache. When it comes to the biting, drawing blood is a little bit too much, but I’ve had an infatuation with biting, long before twilight came out, and it had nothing to do with vampires.
To be honest, I don’t understand what it is about twilight that makes people go crazy. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the books, but I was never obsessed with them like some of these other females are. The only thing I’ve ever blamed on twilight is annoying mothers and daughters, the amount of vampire related books that have came out recently, and it’s the only reason anybody knows that Robert played Cedric, and Taylor was SharkBoy.
guest
I would have never dated Edward Cullen. In fact, if I were Bella the books would have ended right in the first time I discovered Edward was a clingy possessive dead guy. Also, I think it’s freaking STUPID that people didn’t expect books to be powerful. That’s the point of writing, to affect and connect people. I have post-potter depression, along with a million other people, so why wouldn’t kids do stuff like that? As far as the DUI girl, she obviously can’t assume responsibility for her actions.
guest
LMAO
orchid / 174 posts
@Orlei@xanga - Funny thing there… um… I was just answering the questions posed at the end of the article. You know, these ones? “Have/Would you ever blamed anything on this series? What do you think of these incidences? What else do people blame on Twilight?” There was no reason to point out the obvious to me, since I said the same thing you did in much less words. I simply gave my opinion, which is what the author asked of her readers.
orchid / 174 posts
@papillonquotes@xanga - I know, I feel the same way. I really enjoyed the series, and I feel like it’s not just twilight – this happens to all sorts of other series’ and video games especially you hear about this happening. I guess it just comes with the not-quite-right-in-the-head territory.
guest
People are fucking ridiculous. It’s called taking responsibility for your own actions, owning your shit. I’m sorry but there are books/movies far more worse and persuading than twilight. I want to slap the selfish bitch who drove drunk because her boyfriend failed to take her to see the movie, and if you’re using a book to break up with someone, clearly their were issues even BEFORE the book, and you need a “good” reason (if you can even consider this a good a reason at all).
guest
Can you link some of the divorces because of Twilight, because the only one I heard about was from a Facebook parody site.
guest
Not gonna lie, the biting thing sounds hot XD
Everything else is….I don’t have words.
guest
Wow… This is pathetic…
guest
I wish I knew the girls who went out in the woods so I could laugh at them and tell them what idiots they are and how stupid that was.
I have noticed the biting thing! It’s so gross! There’s licking where I’m from to. ._. I’ve been licked twice, grooooooss.
guest
Lol I wouldn’t even disagree with the last. That’s why I hate such stories.
guest
Yup, I wasted about $8 on a movie ticket to watch this sh*** because a former friend asked me to come watch it wit her.
tulip / 5 posts
thats just stupid. i love twilight but who would actually do that for a movie.you goin to jail just mean one less person to fight for a seat over and one more seat to sit down in
tulip / 5 posts
who cares if you people hate twilight in reality they will still be making more money that you people will ever make. so stop hatin nd keep it movin
guest
The only thing that I feel like Twilight could actually be seem as a REAL contributing factor is the biting trend. But that is probably not just Twilight. Let’s not forget True Blood and Vampire Diaries fueling the vampire craze.
guest
Biting is hardly a new thing. It has been done for a long time and for most erotic couples it has nothing to do with some glitter trend.