Possibly the biggest question among viewers’ minds for this Fall’s premiere season has been, “How will CBS kill off Charlie Sheen?”
We were given hints here and there, i.e., we knew it was violent and that Charlie would not appear in the episode at all, but other than that mum’s been the word. Last night, September 19, 2011, all was finally revealed!
The premiere of the revamped “Two and a Half Men” aired and CBS was forced to finally tell us how they killed their main character. We also got to see Ashton Kutcher’s big return to television, but unfortunately, it seems that Charlie’s shoes might be too big for him to fill.
The show opens immediately to Charlie’s funeral scene with a slower version of the famous “Men” theme song, setting a mockingly somber mood. The room is filled with women that Charlie charmed over the years as well as Alan, Jake, Berta, and Evelyn.
But it’s our favorite stalker Rose who is given the honor of breaking the news of how Charlie died while they were in Paris getting married.
Charlie Harper accidentally slipped on a platform and fell in front of a train, his body “exploding like a balloon full of meat. There is slight speculation about whether it was really an accident or if Charlie had a little extra help slipping because Rose mentions that she walked in on Charlie showering with another woman when she came home shopping. Sadly, this mystery will never be solved.
The premiere is full of jokes and avoids the sadness that most funeral episodes usually convey to their audiences. This isn’t surprising since Sheen left on such bad terms with those in charge of the show. What is surprising is the writers get a little jab in at Sheen, by referencing his drug issues at the funeral when one man stands up and claims that Charlie Harper owes him $38,000 for “pharmaceuticals.”
CBS seems to be working very hard to keep the show alive without Sheen. One tactic they have adopted is bringing in famous names for short cameos. This episodes cameos included John Stamos and Jenna Elfman and Thomas Gibson (Dharma and Greg), who go to the condo’s open house.
It’s not until ten minutes into the half-hour long show that Ashton Kutcher shows up outside, soaking wet after attempting to drown himself in the ocean. The suicidal, broken-hearted billionaire isn’t so witty, but has some good comments that fit in with Kutcher’s past roles as the stupidly funny guy.
The new “Two and a Half Men” features a lot more Jon Cryer. While he’s not bad at entertaining a crowd, I can’t deny that I’m not looking forward to him carrying all the punchlines in the upcoming episodes. Replacing a witty Charlie with a stupid Walden (Kutcher) will force the writers to sacrifice the quickfire give-and-take conversations that “Two and a Half Men” has become known for over the years.
It turns out that the show really might need Charlie Sheen and all of his craziness to survive.
Are you still watching “Two and a Half Men”? What did you think of Charlie’s replacement?
guest
This article was an exceptionally well-written review.
I need to go digest that.
guest
Never seen a full episode. Not gonna start now.
lily / 5148 posts
@Grtt@xanga - Same
guest
@Grtt@xanga - Likewise.
daffodil / 1615 posts
I’m sorry but Two and a Half Men is probably one of the dumbest shows that I’ve had the displeasure of having to watch. I gave it several chances because my family likes the show, but I just never found it funny. You can see all the jokes coming from a mile away. Before hearing that Ashton Kutcher was replacing Charlie Sheen, I never thought the show could get any worse, but alas CBS never ceases to amaze me.
guest
a friend told me he watched it and explained it all to me. apparently this rose lady caught him in the shower with another woman tjus killing him by pushing him off the platform sounds justified lol. i never really watched the show before but if ashton is in it… im down. lol
guest
i never realy liked the show. it was not that funny in my opinion.
guest
omg…the premiere was so terrible.
rose / 802 posts
Honestly, I had no idea anyone watched this show to begin with.
guest
I never liked the show since the beginning, but it seems to have a cult following.. good luck to them!
guest
I loved the show when Jake was little…but that’s what happens when you don’t have cable.
magnolia / 1066 posts
I’ve never understood the hype about Two and a Half Men. I watched one episode and felt like I’d wasted my life in a terrible, terrible way.
sunflower / 294 posts
It’s like a completely different show without Charlie Sheen. I don’t see any point in watching it.
I’d also heard about how Charlie would die a few months ago, the rumour was that Charlie slipped and fell while in the shower with another women when Rose walked in on them.
guest
I love the show, and i don’t mind watching the reruns either. I find the show hilarious and although it is probably gonna go down the drain without Charlie i thought the premiere was funny.
WINNING
daisy / 571 posts
i loved that show.
but walden is a horrible name and i don’t think i can get past it.
guest
@ask_ashleyyy@xanga - Same, my boyfriend and my family all love this show, and I just don’t get it. It’s just Charlie Sheen acting like a pig (in other words, being himself) for 30 minutes every week.
I did, however, enjoy the season premiere, especially the Dharma and Greg cameo. I may give it a shot this season – I may actually like it better without Sheen, and anyway I’m an avid fan of How I Met Your Mother, which is on almost right before Two And A Half Men.
daisy / 727 posts
I like 2 1/2 Men and randomly watch it when it’s on, but I don’t go out of my way to watch it except for last night. I was really turned off by the whole thing. The funeral was awkward and it was obvious that the producers/writers/directors were trying to get in their final jab at Sheen. I just thought it was really low of them and I just don’t think it’s right to make that big of a joke about a funeral.
rose / 791 posts
I loved the first four seasons of Two and a Half Men, but as Jake grew older, it got boring and really predictable.
guest
I’ve never been an avid Two and a Half Men viewer. Mostly watch reruns they put on during the week or weekend. I watched the premiere because it was after How I Met Your Mother. It was okay. I wouldn’t be surprised if this is the last season, unless Walden suddenly becomes an interesting character. Because he really isn’t.
Also, as Jake gets older, he becomes way less likable.
rose / 903 posts
I didn’t know people watched this show…
guest
I think I’m going to have to give it another chance before I decide if I’m going to enjoy it or not. By how the first episode went, I don’t enjoy it. At all. And I think, even though Charlie Sheen did leave on bad terms, the writers COULD have been the bigger people and had more respect for this characters death, and made it even in the littlest bit, more serious, rather than just those few moments the character of Alan had with his urn, but they didn’t, so I frown on them for that. The whole time while watching the episode, I felt that Ashton Kutcher’s character was a really whiney version of Charlie, and I’m not going to enjoy that humor. It seems as if there are two Alan’s now. I also found there was an empty hole where Charlie used to be, and the show will never be the same.
dahlia / 2103 posts
My mom loves that show. All I can say is, go Ashton! Representin’ IOWA.
guest
I wonder how they’re going to change the opening, it’s been the same for so long!!
sunflower / 296 posts
It doesn’t really matter to me on whether it’s good or bad, when the show is supposed to be on its last season anyway. So far, Jon Cryer really does have enough room to spread his comedy legs without Sheen, and I want to see that, too.
guest
It was pretty funny
and I will probably most definatly watch this new season
guest
I didn’t like it when Sheen was on it, and I’m not wasting my time watching it to see if it got any better.
guest
I actually thought the new episode was hilarious….
daisy / 647 posts
I’ve never liked that show at all, the humor bores me to death, and to me it’s simply not funny. Every time my friend made me watch this show, I wanted to punch myself in the face.
guest
sheen is the man. it’s simple, you can’t kill off the main character and keep the show going. This is likely the last season if at all a full season.
guest
@Grtt@xanga - Me neither, and I don’t know anyone who watches it. Actually, I kind of wonder how they make all that money, and who exactly is tuning in, because I never hear about it!
guest
@WaitingToShrug@xanga - Probably because it’s such a bland, formulaic shitty sitcom that no one really even wants to admit they’re too lazy to change the channel when it comes on.
I mean, 8 Simple Rules kept going even after John Ritter passed away… but it wasn’t nearly as good as it was before, and it kind of became a completely different sort of show without the main character. I think this will likely be the fate of Two and a Half Men, thankfully… People will get over the novelty of Ashton Kutcher being on the show and it will get boring and they’ll stop watching. :/
guest
@WaitingToShrug@xanga - The whole Charlie Sheen fiasco is that only time I started to hear about it since the first season. I’ll stick to shitty special effect Hercules, lol. (I am so obsessed with that show lately..)
lily / 5148 posts
@Grtt@xanga - You mean the one with Kevin Sorbo? Yes, it’s pure love ;P
guest
@Hinase@xanga - Yep! Watching it right now, actually, lol.
guest
I thought the show was lame before and now that Ashton is in it, it’ll be even worse – Ashton is one of the worst actors ever.
peony / 1 posts
i feel it was distasteful for the writers to add the part where the man in the funeral stands up, and says charlie owes him money for pharmectucal drugs. we all know they’re angry at him for his comments his made and how he’s acted but he has a drug problem, and this isn’t someone who is just addicted to cocaine or alchol. these individuals need to put their feelings aside and stop thinking on how they can get revenge on charlie, and remember the people who will be affected because of all this stupidly.think about his children, his father who especially seems to look so hurt and just dosen’t know what else to do. the problem with our society today is that it’s all about money and noone cares who they care who they step on who they hurt to get it. so to the directors,writers and producers of theshow i have no respect for you. what you did was immature and showed the viewers how ignorent you are. we would think you all would have had more common sense.