Hallmark is in hot water with the NAACP over a graduation greeting card that the civil rights group claims contains snippets of racist dialogue.
A member says that the card’s recorded message evokes “children bantering and making fun of blackness,” and in particular that a cartoon character who mentions “black holes” sounds instead to be saying “black wh*res.”
Hallmark is defending itself, saying the theme of the card–which has been out for 3 years–is, innocuously enough, the solar system, and they’ve even provided transcripts of the card’s dialogue. And yet, they’re still pulling the cards from stores.
Now, you guys know I like to call attention to potential instances of racism, but seriously….is this the Onion?
guest
Good grief… doesn’t the NAACP have anything better to do? Clearly not.
guest
It clearly sounded like “BLACK HOLES” to me not “black whores” lol; why would someone even believe that a cartoon greeting card that geared toward children from Hallmark would say the word “whore” or any foul language in it, anyway?
daffodil / 1525 posts
UGH FACEPALM SO HARD fuck calling the race card (no pun intended) for everything
guest
Seriously?… I dont see anything racist about this… They are talking about the solar system.. NOT races… People make big deals over nothing…
guest
Are they serious? I wanted to hear “whores”, but I just didn’t. Sounds like “holes” to me.
guest
Clearly they feel the constant need to make themselves feel important and they probably have absolutely nothing to attack right now so they chose this harmless card. It sounded nothing like “whores.” These people are so stupid, they are just embarrassing themselves and don’t even realize it.
rose / 791 posts
I knew this was going to be you, haha. This is fine.
rose / 903 posts
Ugh. Really.
guest
Is it just because I’m white that I don’t get it, or is it because I can hear properly?
tulip / 23 posts
I cleary heard the word ”holes.”
guest
@thepsychoticraccoon@xanga - It’s because your not a moron.
guest
yeah i definitely heard “holes” and also, “watch out planets” which i think should have clarified it further. sorry. dumb.
guest
Lols. The panties are bunchin’. Over nothing as usual.
sunflower / 397 posts
After the whole racist past of the USA, I can get that the NAACP would keep an eye open for racist things, but really?? It’s pretty clear that this card isn’t racist at all… Also, am I the only one noticing that it’s all elderly-ish people? No offense to anyone, but elders don’t exactly have a rep. for having the clearest / best hearing…
guest
I’m rolling my eyes so hard right now.
guest
I definitely heard HOLES. Wow.
guest
WTF.
This proves the world is getting stupider and stupider.
daisy / 568 posts
Someone really has nothing to do except stroll around Hallmark looking for racist cards? I got this card for my cousins graduation and i played it over and over and over again and never did I hear the word “whores.” I always heard “yeah you black WHOLES” they clearly say the “L.” I don’t know what is wrong with these people. I love hoops and yo-yo!!
guest
This is soooo ridiculous.
dahlia / 2382 posts
Totally heard holes. H-O-L-E-S!! This is why I get sick of black publications & groups now. I’m part black but they get excited over the stupidest shit now or shake up something that isnt that serious. There’s worse shit going on concerning people of color than a $3 graduation card.
guest
What the hell…I replayed the part with the card’s recording five times and I can’t even PRETEND that it sounds like anything but “holes”… -_-
guest
Let’s be clear, the NAACP does NOT speak for all black people in America and in many ways, I think the NAACP is falling out of step with black people of today. Rather than fight to build stronger black communities and reduce violence in the ghettos, the NAACP has been reduced to a joke because this is what people think of when they think of what the NAACP does nowadays. By using your organization’s cloat to focus on dumb trivial shit like this, you undermind REAL concerns that black people are actually struggling with.
guest
This story is old.
guest
That’s ridiculous.
guest
The NAACP should start getting fined every time they incorrectly pull the race card.
rose / 802 posts
I’m a member of the NAACP & so often think they do wonderful, necessary work. Right now is NOT one of those times.
guest
Stupid. Painfully stupid. The audio chip is clearly saying ‘black holes’, not ‘whores’. If it said ‘whores’, I’d be among the first to defend the NAACP’s actions, but this is much ado about nothing.
sunflower / 290 posts
wtf? why would anyone put the words “black whores” into a graduation card? it’s like beyond obvious that it says holes. it’s not as if there’s any other phrase in the card that could also be misconstrued
guest
Some people are offended by absolutely everything. Why would hallmark call someone such a horrible name and think they could get away with it? It’s clearly saying “black holes”. Seriously people…
guest
Really? This is a SMH moment -__-.
guest
Good effing lord, people are so damn oversensitive. Its so incredibly
obvious what the intent of the card is. Seriously if I was the CEO of Hallmark I
would counter-sue for libel and slander.
guest
how bout they focus on the black community, youth violence, and gangs rather than a fucking card. How about get teens to stop shooting up buses and beating the living sense out each other.
Do I have to get in there and do this shit myself to try to help my community? god >_<
guest
i heard “holes.” and i really did try to listen for the r.
guest
Are you f-ing kidding me?!?!?!?!
People hear what they want to hear.
magnolia / 1066 posts
are you kidding me!? this is ridiculous! people get their panties in a wad over the dumbest shit. maybe the problem isn’t perceived racism in cartoony greeting cards, but the types of people who can find racism in the most innocent places.
guest
I got this card for my graduation last year… I didn’t think it was racist at all, and I’m usually quick to say, “That’s racist!!” jokingly to something that isn’t racist at all.
rose / 786 posts
Wow. Really??? Wooooow…..
guest
… i don’t get it? the only thing i found remotely racist was the “black holes” but that isn’t really racist…
guest
I heard black hole’s.
Why is it bad? i don’t understand
sunflower / 281 posts
This is dumb as hell lol. And I love how they took 3 years to notice.
guest
hmm sounds like holes to me……
guest
Ignorant fucks.
guest
Also, if you want to “be treated equally”, then why the FUCK should we allow you to have your own TV channel (BET), college fund (UNCF), AND a fucking national union for your precious race that goes completely without any help at all right? What the fuck ever. Every single black person that went to college in my grad class went for FREE because they’re black yet MY WHITE family paid for ALL my schooling, because “I’m a vanilla face who made life bad for them.” Bitch, last time I checked I’m 20 years old, slavery has NEVER been around for me OR you, and you black people have got it fucking EASY with government assistance and all your other bull shit you get for being black. Take all your hand outs and shut the fuck up, because we arent reaping any benefits and you are. So be happy with it.
guest
yeah, it’s says “black holes” and these people seem to be just looking for something to fight about. Even if they weren’t completely sure whether it said black holes or not, the context of the rest of the card would inform them.
guest
I don’t think the NAACP cares about context clues. I mean, clearly, the characters on that card were talking about the solar system so why would “black whores” be in the middle of that conversation?
guest
You’re kidding right?
guest
This is getting so stupid.
guest
Are you kidding me? And this group wants to be taken seriously?
guest
@headtrippp@xanga - That shit pisses me off. The worst of it is that if there were college funds and scholarships for only white kids, like there are for black students, shit would hit the fan. Fucking ridiculous.
guest
OH MY GOD. notice that these people look quite old and probably can’t hear well… oh well.
guest
@bekkabrutality@xanga - @headtrippp@xanga - It would be nice to qualify for a scholarship that didn’t require a 3.5 or higher gpa. Since I dropped out and got my GED, don’t have any kids, am not the first in my family to attend college, not going for any sort of nursing degree, and my parents make just enough together, I’m pretty fucked financially. I just don’t get why I couldn’t qualify for government financial aid… I wasn’t even living in the same state as my parents. I was told because I’m not 24 my parents are still expected to help out. Wtf is that shit?
guest
Soooo much fail. That is like really really grabbing at straws there. It sounds nothing like black whores, and even if the audio was jumbled, like really?
guest
Haha I actually got this card for graduation 2 years ago. Never once did I think it said whores. I heard holes too.. and when they say “watch your back” they clearly say “and you planets” before it so it’s not like it was “and those black holes (or whores), you better watch your back”
guest
They voices are cartoony and it doesn’t even make sense for them to be saying black whores. Ugh, this is stupid. It was stupid 3 years ago.
guest
It says “holes.” I’ve seen/heard the card.
guest
Da fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck??
guest
If you have to stick the card up your ear to hear this ONE world that maybe sounds like whore after the word black. Has anyone ever thought about someone actually refering to a black prostitue, a real slut, or a crazy female dog of a person… if you take offense then maybe you have a guilty conscious about something.lol. Everyone has an accent but I dont get pissed about people mispronouncing words. These characters are cute…. some people need to get lives. Im black and my “so called people” suffered a long time ago. All I know is that my daughter was not born with the burdon of all that hatred. She’s a quarter black, looks totally white so maybe she can get passed the ignorance of sterotyping people over color. I swear if I have one more civil rights class, I am going to scream!!!! NCAA are making a bad name for themselves by digging up bad memories. I would like the past to stay the past. Thank you.
guest
“aaaaaaaaahhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaa weeeeee graduatin’ let’s get some _itches and _oes!!!!” did they said that? oh wait, no they did not ^_^.
I am racist U.u
guest
*yawn* Illiterate, much? xD Nothing to argue about we have an African-American President now… hmph what to do what to do “hey they said black in a greetings card! I bet they are mentioning us!!!!!”
guest
@thepsychoticraccoon@xanga - @Yoru_Kendo@xanga - I think it’s because we do not have hearing aids and do not need to press our ears to the card to possibly hear sometihng.
guest
why the fuck do black people always think that the entirety of america is racist against them? get the fuck out if you don’t like it!!!!
i’m pissed the whites took african slaves…made trashy people come into this country and have constant HATE against america and whites over a fucking hundred years later! seriously….get the fuck out!!! don’t like shit here…go back to africa where your ancestors came from
hate on this…i’m just saying what everyone else is thinking
guest
wtf.
guest
I heard HOLES. People need to get over stupid shit.
guest
@dead_poetic009xx@xanga - You sound pretty hateful yourself.
Maybe you should consider to take your own advice: if you don’t like the shit here, get the fuck out.
Whites weren’t here first.
Native Americans were.
And Europeans treated them terribly– that’s pretty trashy itself.
Then white americans were too lazy to work their own plantations.
And now you’re complaining about others being trashy.
Go back to where your ancestors came from if you don’t like it. Assuming you’re white– your ancestors had been immigrants too.
I’m just saying what I’m thinking. The overlooked history.
Or maybe you’re just trollin’ patrolling.
But, I digress–
I heard “Holes” too.
guest
They were looking to cause a scene, and found that holes and whores sound similar if you can’t hear the L. So they cried and moaned and got their wish. Can this world get any more over-sensitive and stupid?!
guest
I heard black whores as well BUT I would have quickly realized that it said black holes when you look at the rest of the fucking card…
guest
@lollol_jkjk_no@xanga - believe me…i can’t WAIT to get out of the USA…and who said i was white????
i’m not being hateful i’m being real
guest
Totally heard holes.