Lovelyish

Swift. Hands down.

they both look good!

although, personally i prefer the pink dress

Taylor Swift. No competition.

The pink one has more character… I’d have to go with swift. 

Taylor! I love the color and her hair looks good too!

I think they both look great :3

Taylor! It doesn’t look that great in black. I love the bottom but the top part sorta reminds me of an apron ><”

They both look good, but I like it on Talyor. 

I love the pink dress and Taylor Swift definitely pulled it off well.

taylor is taller and the angle of her pose with her hands on her hips accentuating her waist looks more elegant whereas the puffy black dress on katie makes her thin frame look bloated, which was partly the style of the dress and partly due to the angle of the pic. maybe if the similar angle where we can see the side view curve of katie’s back, then it would look more flattering. advantages are in taylor’s favor, so she wore it better.

The black!

wasn’t this asked before?

Taylor!

Hmm. Tough call. I think Taylor Swift looks better, but they book look realy REALLY good in it.

@Erika_Steele@xanga - I did a get the look with this dress, so I think that’s what you’re remembering. It’s a gorgeous dress!

Taylor just because I prefer the dress in pink. 

Holmes. Swift has no shape and that color washes her out.

taylor

@ashleya - I think that might be.  I think I said I’d like it better in black.

Conceptually, I do. I just don’t like it on Katie Holmes.

both!

Love Swift.. but, Holmes wins this one.

Taylor. Her shoes match waayyy better. I like the black better, but I don’t like her shoes.

i like katie. taylor’s looks like everything else she wears.

They both look good. I like the darker dress more, though.

taylor marry me! haha

Katie Holmes

tswift<3

katie… but both look nice

I like both of them, but since I think taylor’s shoes compliment her dress better, I’m voting for her.

Taylor’s pops more, Katie’s kinda blends in with her hair. Although they both look great! I want that dress, it’s so gorgeous

Katie!! F’sho!!

Taylor Swift.

taylor. but i think it’s ugly.

Katie. 

I don’t like the pink.

Katie.

I’m going to say Katie by a long shot, even though it seems like mostly everyone disagrees. It’s not flattering on Taylor. The cut makes her figure look boyish. The pink color, although pretty, washes her out WAY too much. Katie has the presence for a look like this. Instead of the girly sweetness which Taylor displays, Katie’s got a rocking confidence that goes great with the edgy, black dress. Her curves and color add to the dress, instead of taking away from it.

The top is weird. 

@mara_says_rawr@xanga - I agree.

Taylor Swift

Tswift

KATIE HOLMES BITCHES

Katie.

i don’t like the dress.

taylor. it makes kate look fat.

Both.

swift, although her eyebrows look horrible in that shot.

It’s about the same.

taylor ^^v

I’m going to have to go with Taylor, it doesn’t look flattering in color or body shape with Katie at this angle =/

Katy Holmes!

Oh God! Taylor Swift wore it way better, I personally don’t like Katie Holmes, but its not because of that, I just don’t like how looks on Katie, the dress looks flat on her, on Taylor it has more volume. I like the dress better in navy, but Taylor wore it better.  Love you Taylor!