The more teen girls are involved in Facebook, the more they may be at risk for negative body image and for developing eating disorders, says a new study.
Researchers at the University of Haifa in Israel surveyed teens about their social media habits:
The girls, with a median age of 14.8, were asked about their TV-watching, Internet and magazine-reading habits. Regarding television, the girls were queried about whether they watched popular shows that present an extreme focus on Barbie doll-like “beautiful, voluptuous and thin” women. They also filled out questionnaires on their desire to be thin, satisfaction (or lack of same) with their bodies, weight and eating.
The Haifa researchers found that there was a direct connection between the extent of their Facebook involvement and a greater number of eating problems. The more they were on the social network, the more they were likely to suffer from bulimia (eating a lot of food and then vomiting it) or anorexia (starving themselves), dissatisfaction with their figures and pursuit of a weight-loss diet.
The researchers concluded that the more time you spend on Facebook, the more you tend to be self-obsessed (oof), so naturally you’re more likely to be focused on your own appearance.
What do you think, Lovelies? Can you see how Facebook could encourage disordered eating, or is this study a bunch of bull?
guest
BS.
rose / 812 posts
Its a bunch of bull shit. Websites don’t cause eating disorders, people that are insecure do.
guest
did they consider the possibility that those who use facebook most often do so because of their insecurities or something? i mean, FB can be a sort of affirmation, albeit a shallow one
either way, though, i really don’t buy itBS.
guest
I think it’s total bullshit. It’s like “the music made the teens go crazy” excuse.
guest
Bull.
guest
Such bull.
guest
@UnconventionalButterfly@xanga - I hope you’re not implying that insecure people are responsible in and of themselves for their eating disorder…it’s so much more than that
rose / 853 posts
Correlation does not imply causation. I say this so much.
guest
correlation =/= causation. there could be a third variable involved (e.g., individuals at risk for eating disorders spend more time on facebook andare more self-obsessed). Just because a study shows a connection between two things does NOT mean a causal relationship can be concluded. ><
sunflower / 370 posts
Hm. Interesting question. No, I don’t think that facebook “causes” eating disorders, but I can see how their would be a correlation. If you think about it, facebook is mostly a way to “spy” on others for a lot of people. And if you are constantly looking at other people’s perfect pictures, reading their glowing statuses, and envying their wall hopping with friends and admirers, it may make it easier for teen girls to become unhappy with themselves. I would say the same thing about too much of any media that focuses on other people though- celebrity gossip, women’s magazines, etc, especially if these girls are spending more time with said media than with their family and friends.
orchid / 190 posts
i think there was a study a while back that said avid facebook users were especially narcissistic. kinda makes sense…
orchid / 140 posts
sounds completely valid to me, but i don’t think a website itself is strong enough to have enough influence to make someone binge/starve.
guest
LOL. Are sociologists doing these studies? I know it just states the correlation, but it’s implying that Facebook is the cause of having an eating disorder.
Here’s how it may work: Insecure girl wants to lose weight, but instead of working out and eating healthy, she goes on the Internet to avoid eating. Oh she happens to stumble upon Facebook. Then she spends a ridiculously long amount of time there. WAPAHHHH.
How does this “study” do anything for society anyway?
lily / 5148 posts
@MiaJoyTheWriter@xanga - agreed
guest
considering the site is all about image, it’s no surprise that anyone would be pressured to appear perfect or desirable somehow.
guest
Bullshit, eating disorders are about more then some stupid website
guest
Uhm. I find that a complete load of shit.
Enough said.
guest
I think it’s bullshit, a girl has an eating disorder because of the pressures she is putting on herself to look a certian way not because of facebook.
guest
Why say FaceBook? why not say your computer makes you fat? i know sit in front of my computer and drink massive amounts of soda..that could make me fat too.
guest
That’s quite extreme, but I gotta say, It could happen.
guest
@UnconventionalButterfly@xanga - AMMMMMEENNN.
guest
So THIS is where the social sciences are spending their time? Getting a doctorate is supposed to be use to actually do valid research, not for gossiping purposes.
guest
this is a load of shite. if you are the kind of person to have an eating disorder, something will trigger it. Be it MTV, Facebook or bullying – it’s within you.
guest
everything causes everything -___- B S !
guest
Ohk.
guest
Stupid.
sunflower / 316 posts
Correlation =/= Causation
guest
There’s a difference between correlation and causation.
guest
not buying it.
sunflower / 290 posts
correlation does not imply causation. it’s entirely possibly that looking at other popular girls all day could trigger an eating disorder in teens who are prone to such things, but it’s equally possible that teens who are being triggered towards an eating disorder in some other way are also more likely to obsess over themselves and others, leading to more facebook use.
guest
That is dumb and a waste of time and money for scientific research, people have always and will always be self absorbed and people will always be insecure.
guest
Bull. Correlation does not equal causation.
orchid / 182 posts
Seems logical. Social networks are all about putting yourself out there to be seen by the world. The more you want to be noticed, the more they may feel as if they must be stick thin to be “beautiful”. And all the bullying and FB haters don’t make it any better. Eh…. When will America learn?
guest
Leaning towards bullshit. Although it may be true that people with eating disorders spend more time on FB simply because of the isolating nature of EDs.
guest
The more they were on the social network, the more they were likely to suffer from bulimia or anorexia.
That’s not what we call “direct connection” in science land. It’s what we call correlation. Not causation. Yes?
guest
maybe people who spend more time on facebook also spend more time on pro-ed sites? or maybe insecure people are a.)prone to ed’s and b.) prone to isolating and stalking others on fb instead???
orchid / 169 posts
First of all, the girl in the picture look 10…not 14. haha
guest
Or, eating disorders cause facebook use. I see that as likely, because eatng disorders make you feel alienated sometimes, meaning you spend time viewing your friend’s lives, wishing you were ________ (skinny, pretty, funny, smart…) enough to participate. Facebook gives you that window-shopping opportunity. Besides, I often like to look at facebook and see very unappealing picture of my friends taken while they were drunk…. makes me feel good about myself, lol
tulip / 16 posts
misleading title. factor A doesn’t cause factor B, factor C influences both factor A and factor B, blah blah blah experimental talk.
they’re just trying to hook you in for a read and mislead you by the research. silly social psychologist-scientists!
guest
I kind of think its bullshit because facebook actually HELPS me since I have such a positive group of friends.
guest
Correlation does not imply causation.
guest
They spend more time on social networking sites, because of the time they save by not eating…obviously.
guest
Seriously? Whateverrrrrrr. “Researchers” need to stop connecting 2 things that have nothing to do with each other.
sunflower / 271 posts
the internet doesn’t cause anything…girls who dont have brains cause problems
guest
I can see that happening considering these girls are young and impressionable. I do see a lot of people on Facebook who are self-obsessed… I know for sure my kids aren’t going to be joining any internet social networks until they hit college.
guest
It’s Crap ! Plain and simple !
guest
Even if facebook usage is linked to eating disorders, it is a correlation nothing more. Cause and effect cannot be determined as there are a million other variables involved. Eating Disorders are way more complex than that. Maybe it has an influence on some, but that’s all….
guest
@milkplus_synthemesc@xanga - Thank you. Exactly.
guest
I think it is bull, along with most the comments. The thought is already in the persons head. Sure, it may trigger the start of an eating disorder by cyber bullying, but that is with every social site.
guest
Facebook makes everybody worse.
guest
That doesn’t make Facebook the cause of anything. That just means that insecure people spend more time on the internet, and that’s not a surprise.
guest
@allisonnbby@xanga - Ah agree with you 100%! Thats exactly what I was thinking while reading this.
Some people are just going to feel bad about themselves no matter what, and people are going to blame the media, the internet, whatever.
guest
Facebook and every show, magazine, media coverage article there ever is in the history of the world!! My god, this isn’t new. Body image issues in females and males start from everything and anything, not just FB.
guest
When I was into my ED, being online made it ALOT worse. Do I believe the internet causes them? No. But they make an already existing problem worse, or if you already have the ‘bullets’ so to speak of having an ED, certain websites can pull the trigger into having a full blown one. Xanga for example…?
guest
Look, some girls are born gorgeous and some are not. Let’s not bother with the whole “beauty is only skin deep” bullshit. Beauty is what it is, all right? No website, magazine cover, or TV show should motivate you to give in to eating disorders. It’s the insecure people who’ve never come to terms with themselves who fall victim to all kinds of psychological nonsense. If you want to starve yourself, go ahead. Your loss. If you would voluntarily stick a finger down your throat so you could literally regurgitate your last meal for the day, go ahead. Your loss. Don’t act as if some evil force out there were intentionally forcing you to do those things. It’s you killing yourself.
sunflower / 323 posts
== really ?
guest
I see where they’re coming from. I used to have Facebook and yeah I did get a little self obsessed. For example I felt like I needed to have only pictures of me that look good for it to be seen and have a lot of conversation posted on my wall so I would seem “popular” but I’m not like that anymore since I permanently deleted it. Facbook did kind of lower my self esteem though because sometimes I would be tagged into picture I didn’t know were taken and I looked pretty horrible. Since I was tagged I’m pretty sure a lot of people I know and don’t know saw it. A lot of girls on Facebook tends to flaunt around their ultra thin bodies too :/