A couple months ago, Lovelyish published a post regarding Crystal Renn getting mad for having her photos photoshopped to be thinner than she really is. Well, it seems the controversy of Photoshopping continues on.
Crystal Renn is featured on the latest magazine, titled Paper Planes. The black and white photos of Crystal Renn provide a vintage yet elegant feel to the spread, but I can’t help but notice that there are a few photos that don’t even look like the beautiful model!
Can we say a “Photoshop Disaster” is amongst us? The photo on your left, titled “Not Photoshopped” or at least not AS photoshopped, shows Crystal with curves while the photo on the right shows Crystal in a very slimmed down figure. And yes, these two photos are in the same magazine photoshoot, and I don’t think those jeans can slim THAT much off.
Having been criticized for her “yo-yoing” weight, maybe it’s really not that she’s “dieting,” maybe the blame should be put on what the magazines are portraying with the help of Photoshopping.
Do you think that plus-sized models should be photoshopped to be thinner? What’s your take on this continuing issue, Lovelies?
guest
I have no clue why they would photoshop her. She is not fat. She looks good.
hydrangea / 66 posts
i think its just the clothes shes wearing and the way shes standing
guest
I do not understand why curves would be undesirable… Most women have them.
I would like to see those who publish the photos. Are so thin?
guest
@Starving_For_Perfection__x3@xanga - That’s what I thought, too.
guest
it doesn’t look like a drastic difference. high waisted underwear is unflattering and makes the hips appear wider than they actually are even on slim women.
she looks like the girl from the prison break tv show, robin tunney.
guest
Why are people so eager to blame? As a model myself, I have learned that lighting and angles can make all the difference. It’s totally believeable to me that both photos can be of the same shoot and be completely unretouched. Don’t automatically pass blame on photo editors unless you are there when it goes to print.
guest
I don’t see much of a difference….
guest
Pardon my language, but how the FUCK is she plus sized?!
guest
@kppuglisi@xanga - agreed! wtf?
guest
Plus sized models should NOT be photo-shopped to look thinner; especially not Crystal. She is a model that is a well known plus sized hero. She is gorgeous, curvy and hot.
guest
Plus sizes shouldn’t be photoshopped that much. Maybe a bit just to make the image look cleaner, but not to drastically change the body of the model. Especially plus sized models since they’re supposed to be catering to a different crowd then ultra thin minus size models. And even the thin models shouldn’t be overly shopped, but meh photo retouchers often get caught up in the retouching and just keep going, sometimes they don’t even realize how much they change the person until they’re done and then they spent so much time they just leave it that way.
guest
ohhh I would love to look like the unphotoshopped version of her.
tulip / 22 posts
No I don’t think she must be or even could be photoshopped. In fact, if the photographer doesn’t think they are pretty with their actual weigt, why doesn’t he take another model ??? There is no need to take a plus size model to slimmer her…
tulip / 22 posts
@brittany_7x@xanga - She is not plus size here(because extremely photoshopped), but she is indeed.
Here, it’s more obvious for exemple
http://www.ninapeople.com/i/2010/7/34603_s.jpg
guest
I don’t care if the first one was photoshopped, she looks really great in that one.
guest
she is considered plus sized?? what a friggin’ joke…the whole industry should just be taken out back and shot…they make me tired…
guest
@kppuglisi@xanga - In modeling, anything over 6 is plus-sized.
guest
How many times do we have to ask this question. Who cares? These pictures don’t look that much different from what she really looks like.@MissAshleyXOXO@xanga - I agree with you. Lighting makes a huge difference in how someone looks in a photo.
sunflower / 271 posts
im sorrry did you just refer to her as a plus size model/??? wtf shes not even fat!1111 the fact that they photoshoped her i the first place is rediculous but i cant believe you just refered to her as plus size..
guest
i don’t see why the photoshopped picture is bad?? she looks perfectly fine. as models they don’t want any bulges, and that just happens naturally no matter what you do so they fix it. people need to get over photoshopping models and celebrities, it’s supposed to look good so they make it look perfect
daisy / 557 posts
She’s so prettyyyyy.
guest
i think curves are beautiful.. i don’t know why anyone would photoshop them off.
i wish i had curves!
guest
I like her fat ass better when it’s photoshopped.
guest
@Starving_For_Perfection__x3@xanga - me too.
magnolia / 1354 posts
@JusticeCho@xanga - i agree. if they are “plus sized” then, why bother hiring the model if you’re still going to photoshop them looking like that!
magnolia / 1354 posts
@bamxocandy@xanga - yea, when i think of plus sized, i don’t see her that way, too! But, in the modeling world, she’s labeled as that. ; O
sunflower / 276 posts
@akanita@xanga - Exactly! And don’t men love curves? Hello! Yes, girls and women can be slender, but stick thin is just unreal!
The model industry… -sigh-
sunflower / 271 posts
@watermoolen@xanga - thats just absolutly ridiculous
guest
She wasn’t photoshopped. She’s lost a lot of weight. It’s a big scandal because she’s not been labeled as a ‘hypocrite’.
guest
photoshop takes out the beauty of everything now.
tulip / 8 posts
It honestly doesn’t look overly photoshopped to me. The poses and outfits are different, and you’d be surprised how a good pair of skinny jeans can make you look pounds lighter! Also, in the first picture, she has her legs pressed together, which generally makes your thighs look bigger. In the second photo, she has her legs apart, which makes them appear smaller as they’re not touching. He thighs still go out from the waist, while most photoshopped models have straight lines. I’m sure it has been touched up and photoshopped a bit, but that’s to be expected.
guest
Again, you idiots who write these articles do not know what ‘plus sized’ is. Stop writing this shit if you can’t even categorize people correctly, unless you’re just screwing up to get a reaction out of people- if so, congratulations.
guest
@Kyuketsuki_no_Megami@xanga - google Crystal Renn. She is considered a plus sized model.
guest
eh, it doesn’t look that bad. at least she’s not missing an arm or a leg.
guest
she looks the same to me…
guest
She is beautiful and definitely should not be photoshopped!!
guest
@Kyuketsuki_no_Megami@xanga - The writer is not an idiot, in the world of modeling plus size is viewed much different than how you or I view it. Even a size 6 is considered plus size
guest
She should be very angry, they are inadvertently telling her she inst good enough not to be photo-shopped. I say stop photo shopping her because she is good enough shes not perfect and she doesn’t need to be, all she has to do is be real.
Please check out http://www.miiryshopinc.com
guest
lol… i disliked reading her book anyways so might as well be done to her
guest
it’s easy to blame photoshop when most don’t understand how much of a difference posing and lighting can make
guest
they photoshopped the boobs away!(insert tears here) SOMETHING MUST BE DONE!!
orchid / 221 posts
That can’t be plus sized… O_o
guest
This is definitely messed up. she may be plus size but she’s still pretty, there’s NO reason to change her, she’s beautiful how the she because of how she is. I don’t get the media.
guest
damn she’s hott.
guest
I think it makes no sense to photoshop “plus-sized models” to be thinner – isn’t the point that they’re “plus-sized”?
guest
uhm.. shes not even plus sized. shes smaller than me. and I’m a 7…
guest
She doesn’t look very different, and you can’t compare, since those are two different pictures. Also, I’m pretty sure that’s a corset she’s wearing in the ‘Photoshopped’ one.
guest
@RawrYouDo@xanga - in the modelling world, that IS plus sized, sadly.
guest
How can you tell?
guest
She looks beautiful in the first picture!
I agree her thighs look a lot smaller in the second picture, and a different shape to boot. If they don’t want models the shape they are, they shouldn’t hire them. I want to see real women, not animations of what the media want the female form to be.