Lovelyish

I don’t think either of them did it wrong per say, but I think it compliments Carrie Underwood’s face shape more.

carrieeee

I don’t like these ones at all… Rachel McAdams had really nice ones a while back.

Carrie

Simpson’s

JESSICA SIMPSON she’s gorgous! 

Jessie’s. Because it’s not as prominent, so you have to sort of look at her hair and go, “Ohhh, there’s a braid! Cool.” 

They both did. Beautiful!

I think they both look great!

Is it just me, or does Jessica’s hair look dirty?

To be compltely honest I don’t really like either. But if I were to do my hair like that it would look more like Carrie’s.

They both are bad examples.

I like Carrie’s more but she has too long of a forehead to do that, it ends up emphasizing it more (sadly I have a similar problem).

Carrie

Jessica Simpson

They both look scary lol ; 

I like Carrie’s braid more, but is it just me or does she have waay too much make-up on?

I think both look nice.

Carrie !

I gotta go with Carrie

neither. i don’t like this look.

They both look fine, but I guess I’d go with Carrie because her braid is neater.  

Well they both look really cute but I like the way Jessica did her hair-it’s tighter and kinda molds intot he rest of her hair.

I think it looks fine on either of them, but I personally like it better on Carrie Underwood.

They both look fine but I like Carrie’s better.

I think they both pull it off, because they both tweaked it a little to suit their face shapes.  Edge goes to Jessica – I like the subtlety of her braid just a teeny bit more, and I love the fact she’s wearing a NKOTB t-shirt.

They both look good 

i like jessica simpson’s much much better,. carrie has too long of a forehead not to have bangs…

Carrie.

neither, they’re supposed to start further over to the other side.

They both look adorable, but I love all things Jessica so… Jessica!

jessica, i like that her’s doesn’t stick out as much.

they both look nice, but Carrie’s is better

Carrie, I like it better when the braid isn’t back so far. But I don’t really care for either of them

Both look good, but Carrie’s serves its purpose well as a natural headband

both are cute, but Carrie’s look more interesting.

I wish I could pull that off.

carrie.

I like them both. It all depends on whether how long you like it. It looks great on both of them. 

i like carries because the braid goes completely down the side of her hairline & it looks more sleek.

@direwolf005@xanga - Ah! Yes, she does! At first I thought she looked similar to a man dressed as a woman…or a drag queen…but then I thought…no…that’s not it.

But yes. Now I realize…she Does have too much makeup on!

Anyway,
I like Jessica’s look better.

carrie (:

I would say Carrie, just cos she’s prettier, but to be honest they both look great

i like carrie’s.

Carrie’s, but they’re both amazing nonetheless

I guess I would have to go with carrie’s.

both are cute

they look the same to me lol.
both blonde and wave with the bangs over, i dont see any difference.

Jessica Simpson.

definitely carrie… idk now that jessica’s put on a lot of weight, her face looks pudgier so she looks younger, and then with that braid it looks like she’s trying to look younger.  like some 20 yr old who’s trying to look like a minor on a fake underage porn site lol

carrie

Jessica Simpson, def.

Both look nice, but I like Jessica’s more.

Carrie for suuure! How could you even compare that?!

Jessica’s but Carrie’s frames her face better

@paige089@xanga - Interesting?

Jessica’s is subtle and messy in a cute way. But Carrie’s is a little more dressed up. Both are good for different outfits/occasions. Carrie’s forehead IS SO BIG! I think I see a vein. Carrie looks phenomenal with bangs, I adore her bangs. 

I think they both look gorgeous!! =D

It looks good on them both.

carrie’s braid is better but it fits jessica’s hair and face shape wayyy better. also carrie looks really old in this picture. 

Jessica Simpson is FAT, so she automatically loses.

I like Jess Simpson’s

They both look good! I like Carrie’s better though!

Ew, neither.

……………they both look the same…………………

@JadedPoser – wtff.

carrie, but they both look gorgeous!

carrie.

i like simpson one more. but both look fine

I like both. 

Carrie!

agree with @pixiedustandreams@xanga

okay jessica’s would be better if she parted her hair more. but carrie’s is messy, like she only parted the part where its braided and the rest of her part is more to the center. 

I’d say jessica simpson’s looks better this time!