Lovelyish

Gisele, obviously. Zoe looks like she got into a fight with a khol pencil.

I don’t like it on either of them.

Gisele.

Gisele

They both did it right, but Zoe’s eye shadow and liner is heavier.  *facepalm*

@betterdesigned@xanga - Agreed.

they both look messy.

so neither.

gisele. it’s more subtle and doesn’t make her look like a raccoon.

I’m not the biggest fan of either, but Gisele definitely looks better. Zoe’s eyeliner is way too heavy.

that’s not winged, that’s a smoky eye.

durrrr.. 

eehh. neither but if i really have to pick one, gisele! But you know who does great winged eyeliner? figure skater yuna kim, she rocks the winged eyeliner look imo

They both kind of look like they went too heavy. Although Gisele looks better.

gisele. zoe looks like she had a fun little bar fight the previous night.

They Are Both Different Styles.
And I Like Zoe’s Better, Mind You My Lines Would Be Thinner And More Whimsical

Gisele, I need to track down a tutorial on how to do this, I am eyeshadow-challenged!

MP

thepinkandblueblog.com

.. Neither of them, really. :/

I don’t think these necessarily count as “Winged Eyeliner”, they both look like variations of smokey eyes to me. But Gisele’s looks better anyway.

i like the wing on zoe, but the shading on gisele 

I’m not really seein’ the winged eyeliner here…smoky eye perhaps.  This, in my opinion, is winged eyeliner:

http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=2jcu0ec&s=3

Both of those looks are very poorly executed. I truly hope they didn’t pay anyone to do their makeup…I’m hoping they did it themselves…

@babymeatball@xanga - exactly.  Those are smoky eyes.
I don’t like either one of them.  Both look like they woke up and reapplied make-up over the make-up from the night before.

i don’t like either. they don’t even look winged?

gisele

I think less is more when it comes to makeup, so neither.

I don’t like either. Smooth lines are the way to go to make eyes pop so Gisele does not do it at all.

they both look scary? which is hard to do, because they are both very lovely

I’m not too fond of either.. 

Huh, strange. I think Zoe Saldana would’ve nailed it, if not for the massive paint on her face.

Neither.

I think they both got it wrong.

Gisele’s is much cleaner looking, Zoe kind of looks like she left her makeup on from the night before.
Although I like the style, I think it would look better in a lighter color. Too dark for me.

I actually think Zoe’s looks better.

It’s not really winged but, Giselle, definitely; and not just because Giselle is beautiful, Zoe looks like she got into a fight and lost. It makes her brown eye colour pop but not her eyes over all. They look tiny.

Gisele looks way better. Zoe has tooooo much.

Zoe Saldana looks stunning like this!

That’s not winged eyeliner… smokey eyes?

i love it

this isnt even winged eyeliner…… :/

the girl on the right. 

Zoe… it fits her look and she looks sexy.

The girl on the right had it best, but both of them look pretty bad. Haha

def gisele

neither.. but the girl on the left looks liek a mix of beyonce and rhianna 

eh… but if i had to choose, then giselle

Nither! They both look like they jsut got done swimming or something, haha. It’s horrible!!! Both, eww!!

http://news.softpedia.com/images/news2/Winged-Eyeliner-the-Hottest-Makeup-Trend-for-2009-4.jpg

this is much more of a better example of winged eyeliner.
these pictures are just a sad attempt at smoky eye, or what ever the look they were going for.
Surely, they both look like a mess.

Zoe. I like Giseles tho too. 

Neither. They both look like raccoons. 

GISELLE! zoey is wearing way too much, plus her eyes are dark as it is

perhaps if i blur my eyes and squin one of them will look normal…..no, no…still aweful.