Lovelyish

jessica got it right, I dont like the neck part on emmys :/

Jessica.

jessica looks like she’s wearing kevlar… so neither.

i would like both if the neck part on emmy’s was taken off

Meh, neither.

Emmy has a prettier robe, and I really prefer his complexion and hair color.
Jessica’s dress is like … in a kind of metal ? Strange looking, and don’t like her hair color. Looks a bit dirty or.. I can’t find the world in english…

If that neck part wasn’t there I would say Emmy.
I don’t like Jessica’s hair color there.
Both dresses are bad…

Emmy!

Jessica.

Jessica

Emmy Rossum.

EMMY!

jessica! i love that dress.

i really like Emmy’s dress, but i dont liek that neck thing…its like too mucch! So I give her credit, because the rest of the dress is adorable, but Jessica’s dress look’s cute, but I don’t like the bubble thing at the bottom, reminds me of like Prom a bit.
So I don’t think either of them really win or fail, just on part of their dresses is TOO much!

Jessica’s. I’m not a fan of the print on Emmy’s dress.

Jessica did a much better job, but I don’t really like either dress personally.

Jessica

i really like jessica’s dress better!

jessica’s dress is better, but emmy looks nicer.

both look amazing but i kinda prefer jessica

jessica

Emmy. Jessica’s isn’t working for me.

Emmy.

i like Jessica’s better …Emmy’s is a little too busy or something idk…

Jessica

emmy

I like Emmy’s

jessica. emmy, the neck of your dress is awkward.

em.

jessica.. i don’t like the neck on the other one

Jessica’s looks more classy.

Jessica – her dress is more timeless.  Emmy’s is adorable, but will be dated quickly.

I’m going to have to say Jessica.

jessicaaa

both

Jessica, but they both look really nice.

Emmy

jessicas

Jessica, defff.

I like Emmy’s but I hate the neckline!! 

Jessica’s  is just soso, I’ve seen lots of dresses like it beforeCut off the neckline on Emmy’s and I’d give it a 10

they both look FUCKN AWESOME!

jessica.

emmmyyyyy. 

Jessica

P.S

Check out my article on human dog mating, do you love it? hate it? comment me! tell me what you think!

Emmy Rossum would have received my props, were it not for the distracting black-and-white print on the bodice of her dress.

So I guess Jessica Alba wins.

edit: Oh no. I looked at the pic again. Emmy Rossum’s dress would have been perfect without the dress straps and collar. Definitely.

Emmy, the white makes it less boring

Emmy

I…don’t like either….:/

Wow, I actually love both of those dresses! :O
If I had to choose one… I’d probably choose Jessica Alba’s dresss.

JESSICA’S!
Totally.

I like Rossum’s better (her smile is biasing me beyond belief), but I like both of them.

Wow, they both look gorgeous!
Jessica wins, but only by a little bit.

Jessica.

jessica

i like jessica’s better but i would like to see the length of it a little more.

jessica

Jessica always gets it right.

Would help if we had better pictures of them in the dresses. By the looks of that picture, I’d say Jessica. 

Neither, I would like Jessica’s if it was EITHER sparkely top or bottom, both is just really a lot.

emmy rossum.

emmy

I think I like Jessica’s more

Definitely Jessica’s.. Emmy’s looks like it’s trying to strangle her.

I kind of like both dresses.  But, the neck on Emily’s is kind of a turn off, and Jessica’s hair looks terrible…

jessica.